Earnings Labs

Antero Midstream Corporation (AM)

Q3 2012 Earnings Call· Thu, Dec 22, 2011

$21.84

-0.14%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.
Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day, and welcome to American Greetings Corporation Third Quarter Fiscal 2012 Earnings Conference Call. Today's conference is being recorded. At this time, I would like to turn the conference over Mr. Gregory Steinberg. Please go ahead, sir.

Gregory M. Steinberg

Management

Thank you, Jennifer. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to our third quarter conference call. Joining me today on the call are Zev Weiss, our CEO; Jeff Weiss, our COO; and Steve Smith, our CFO. We released our earnings for the third quarter fiscal 2012 this morning. If you not yet have our third quarter press release, you can find a copy within the Investors section of the American Greetings website at investors.americangreetings.com. As you may expect, some of our comments today include statements about projections for the future. Those projections involve risks and uncertainties that could cause the actual results to differ materially from the forward-looking statements. We cannot guarantee the accuracy of any forecasts or estimates, and we do not plan to update any forward-looking statements. If you'd like more information on our risks involving forward-looking statements, please see our annual report or our SEC filings. Previous earnings releases as well as our 10-Qs, 10-Ks and annual report are available on the Investors section of the American Greetings website. We will now proceed with comments from both our CEO and CFO, followed by a question-and-answer session. Zev?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Thank you, Greg, and good morning, everyone. This morning, I will share a few comments on how our ongoing product leadership initiative is supporting our revenue growth, then discuss our capital allocation, systems refresh project, new headquarter building and outlook for the balance of fiscal year 2012. Finally, I'll turn it over to Steve to walk through our financials for the quarter. I'm really delighted with our revenue growth this quarter in both our domestic and international businesses. We believe that our commitment to our product leadership strategy continues to be very successful. Our investments are paying off, and we feel very good about our overall momentum in the marketplace. As a result of our product focus and in-store execution, our recently expanded retail relationships are going well and progressing as planned, helping us to deliver incremental sales through the addition of new space at retail in both legacy and new doors. Also helping drive revenue growth is our leading portfolio of products. The acquisitions of Recycled Paper Greetings, Papyrus and most recently, Watermark allow us to provide uniquely tailored solutions to different channels and different retailers within each channel, thereby bringing a full range of products, from humorous to upscale, to our consumers. We have and will continue to leverage both the unique creative models and unique go-to-market strategies each of these groups creates. This portfolio of brands, together with our complementary strength of manufacturing and distribution, we believe will enable further growth. As part of our product leadership initiative, we continue to bring innovation into our core greeting card brands through a variety of formats, including paper engineering, interactive technology and the use of music, movement, sound and lights. In the past, I provided many examples of these great products, from cards with motion to cards with LCD…

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Thanks, Zev. I have 3 components to my prepared remarks today. I will start with a few brief comments on our consolidated results this quarter, move to a review of our reported segments and then cover a few key components of our financials. After those 3 components, we will open the line for questions. Our consolidated revenue was up $33 million or about 8% from last year's third quarter revenue of $430 million. Included in our $464 million of revenue was a benefit from foreign exchange of about $4 million versus the prior year's third quarter. Holding aside the impact from FX, revenue was up 7%, driven by the combination of organic revenue growth, both internationally and domestically, as well as acquired revenue in the U.K. Our consolidated operating income was $33 million compared to $56 million in the prior year's third quarter. The $23 million decrease was driven by the combination of 3 major factors: the incremental support of our product leadership strategy that Zev shared, increased supply chain costs associated with supporting our expanded retailer relationships and increased product content costs. Our North American segment's earnings of $28 million were down about $23 million versus the prior year's third quarter. Three groups of activities caused the reduced earnings: increased investments in product leadership, including marketing expense of approximately $11 million; higher supply chain costs of approximately $7 million due to both the increased sales volume and increased activity associated with the additional stores we added in the value channel; and a few million dollars for scrap expense and higher product content costs. Our North American segment's revenues of $332 million were up about $14 million compared to the prior year's third quarter. The revenue increase was driven by gift packaging products and everyday greeting cards. Switching now to…

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] We'll take our first question from Jeff Stein with Northcoast Research.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

First question on the top line. Wondering if there was any pull-forward of revenues that, let's say, perhaps may have occurred last year in the fourth quarter that this year got pulled forward to Q3.

Zev Weiss

CEO

No, Jeff, I don't think so. I think it was a pretty consistent quarter.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. So it would seem to me, Zev, that you're talking about top line growth still exceeding 3% for the year. But if you kind of plug -- let's say, hypothetically, if you were to plug a 2% number in for the fourth quarter which, on a pro forma basis, is kind of what you were guiding to for the back half of the year after your second quarter conference call, this would still yield almost a 5% top line increase for the full year. So I'm just wondering, you seem to be giving yourself a lot of room in the fourth quarter. Is there anything that you see from a top line standpoint now that could cause, let's say, a significant drop in revenues year-on-year during Q4?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I don't think so. And I think, if anything, what I shared in the earlier remarks, that there's possible for upside given what we're seeing right now. I think it's too early to sort of declare that and then therefore, say, "Here is the number." But we're hoping that -- I think we feel more confident that the numbers that we gave you when we were last together, we feel more confident that we can hit those numbers, and we see a chance for upside as well.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Now you didn't talk about seasonal cards in your comments. You did speak about every day, so I'm just kind of curious. What was your strategy going into this holiday season with regard to shipments of seasonal? Are you shipping in more or fewer cards to your customers on a same-store basis relative to last year? Because there's -- my understanding is you have this accrual adjustment that you have to make for returns. So how are you planning the seasonal part of your business for the back half of the year?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think in general, last year, we had a good Christmas. So we were feeling -- coming off of a good Christmas, we were hoping that things would continue to be good. There's a lot of moving pieces when you look at shipments. I think when you look at the overall marketplace right now, the general traffic, if you just look at what retailers are reporting right now, they're reporting that they were off to a good start. This week is a critical week. So it's really too early to declare any kind of success around that, but what -- the traffic that people were reporting, at least for the initial parts of Christmas, we saw as well. And we're hopeful that this week is a strong week, but we're not going to really know how it all balances out until we're done. But the big issue for us is obviously not the shipments but how everything sells through. Yes. So we're going to have to wait until we talk next to be able to share how that goes.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Got it. And for the quarter, given the fact that it did, from a top line standpoint, turn out to be better than you expected, where was the upside? Was it account specific? Or maybe you can just kind of give us a little bit of color where the upside came from.

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think a lot of the things that we've been talking about, in terms of where we -- we're seeing a lot of positive activity. We're seeing activity internationally that we're pleased about. We're seeing domestically. We're pleased with what's happening in our digital business, and all that's focused around cards. At the same time, things like giftwrap have been positive for us. And so when you add that all together, these are our core businesses, and we've been talking about the desire to grow in these businesses for a while now. And seeing the results that we saw in the second quarter and what we're now seeing in the third quarter, we're just really pleased with it.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. The margin degradation that you saw on the gross margin line and selling distribution and marketing line, I'm wondering if you could just talk a little bit about how much of that is specific to the kind of what I would call the onetime -- not onetime but the large expansion you saw in the dollar store channel this year. And how much of it is related just to -- perhaps just a higher level of expenses that you're achieving? And are you -- I guess is the model changing would be my question. Have you -- are you able to earn as much margin -- and I'm speaking about EBIT margin, not growth margin but EBIT margin -- in the dollar store channel as you can in the rest of your business? Or is the stronger weighting towards the value channel going to change the margin structure of your entire business?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think, in general, there are shifts that are happening in the business that we've been talking about for probably years. So when you look at the channel migrations that are happening, those continue to happen as they've been happening. And as a result of that, there is a shift in cost structure, and I think you're seeing some of that now. Some of what you're seeing is onetime related in terms of transitions that are happening, and some of them are the shifts that you were speaking about. The challenge that we have as a company and one that you know we've been very focused on for the last many years, which is you got to take cost out of other parts of your business. And I think what you're seeing right now is a continuation of that, where some of it is channel migration where you may see some permanent challenges in terms of what you're seeing in gross margin. Some of it is onetime related with the rollouts that you have going on. And then -- and we believe that there is significant opportunity to take costs out of other parts of our business so that when you're done, you see revenue growth and continued revenue growth in the number of different channels that we have and an operating structure that allows us to get the EBIT margins that we've enjoyed in the past and that we hope to enjoy in the future. And that's -- I think we're right in the middle of that.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. So it sounds like it's kind of a work in progress and that this year -- would it be fair to say that this year could represent kind of perhaps a trough year and that as we look ahead for the next couple of years, you migrate back to your -- closer to the -- maybe your historic EBIT margin, but you're not going to get there next year? Would that be fair?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think when we do our next call, we'll have a better view of what it means for the end of this year and somewhat a better view for what it means going into next year. But I think it would not be appropriate right now to probably get into those details.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Can you talk about -- let's talk a little bit about your free cash flow estimate. You indicated that you expected -- in your last call, you expected to be probably at the lower end of your range. So let's call that $80 million. Now you're $35 million to $50 million, but that revised range that you gave last time, albeit the lower end of the range, that, I assume, did contemplate some increase in capital spending. So the new range is $35 million to $40 million below where you were previously. How much of that is working capital related? And how much of that would be CapEx?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

It's roughly just -- it's roughly half and half between them, a little bit more weighted possibly toward the balance sheet where working capital and other elements, deferred costs too. But it's roughly half and half to answer your question.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Did you guys take on any new customers during the latest quarter? You mentioned an increase in deferred cost. That would either suggest that maybe a contract was renewed or you signed a new contract.

Zev Weiss

CEO

There isn't anything that we would want to get into in terms of individual customers right now.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Right. I mean, without identifying the customer specifically. But can you say that you did or did not -- you have or have not established some new relationships that might be meaningful?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. Even on that, Jeff, it's not something that we would want to be sharing.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Are you done with the rollout of -- are you -- did you complete the rollout of the Dollar General stores this year?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

We're substantially done with the rollout effort associated with the value channel.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. So do those expenses -- I guess, how much of onetime costs associated with that rollout have you incurred this year? And I presume that would drop away as we move into the new fiscal year.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

I'm going to answer the second part of your question, Jeff. The -- it will drop away into the next year. We've -- as we've completed, again, the substantial effort around this, there's still a small tail associated with the value channel, but the exact figure will be shared when all the work is done.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Since it's substantially done, can you give us any kind of estimate in terms of where you're at right now?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

We prefer not to give that at this time, Jeff.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Your international business, revenues were up almost 30%, yet your earnings in this division were down. Can you explain why that is?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. I think you've got 2 things going on there. You've got the acquisition, then you got some expanded distribution. And with the expanded distribution in particular, there's some transition cost associated with that. And on the acquisition, I would expect that more of the profits, given the nature of that business, are going to come in the back part of the year.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Okay. Final question then I'll turn it over to somebody else. You talked about the fact that all in, your new corporate headquarters might end up costing you incrementally under $30 million. And I'm wondering if you could just run through that analysis for us, how you come up with that under $30 million type of number.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Sure, Jeff. I'd be glad to help you. And again, these numbers are all rough because the design, as Zev mentioned in his prepared remarks, it's still a work in process, but let's go through at the highest level. We said that gross is going to be in the neighborhood of $150 million to $200 million. We have incentives that are -- from the state of Ohio and other municipalities that are between $78 million and $93 million, depending on what you look at and how you include these different figures. And then we also -- so that would give you a current building net of incentives figure that would be in the $75 million to $85 million range-ish. We have some deferred maintenance costs also that we mentioned that are in the neighborhood of $30 million. And then we have some potential for sale proceeds on the current world headquarters and which we'd rather not get into a specific figure around. That brings us down to around a $30 million figure.

Jeffrey S. Stein

Analyst · Northcoast Research

Got it. Okay. Have you talked to potential buyers about the facility? Do you have anyone interested in the facility currently?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

We're working on the building at this time. We have engaged a consultant to help us or a broker to help us in the process, and that's all we could comment on at this time.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] We'll take our next question from Carla Casella with JP Morgan.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

On the margin front, gross margin front, can you give us a sense for how much lower the gross margins are on the value cards versus a higher end card? And is it in the card, in the materials itself? Or is it in the cost of distribution, et cetera, to get it to the stores?

Zev Weiss

CEO

So I'm not going to get into the numbers on it. But in general, as you look at it, the cost -- the pricing that you see at retail in the value market -- and the value market is not just individual retailers, because a lot of retailers will participate in the value market in many different ways, but the price points on that could be lowered. And then as a result, there are lower costs associated with that revenue. And we don't execute that revenue in the same way that we do other parts of our business, so there's less of an overall cost as well as the cost that we have in terms of distribution is lower as well. And the combination of all that allows us to capture the margin that we need to on that revenue. And so it's really we treat them in 2 very different ways, and there's 2 different parts of the market. I know that doesn't give you all of the details that you want, but in general, that's the way it works.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. And then the fact that the value chain just started to grow so much for you this year, we should annualize that kind of in early next year? Is that right? Or would it be more mid next year, before we kind of annualize where we are into the value as a percentage of your sales?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. It's -- I think some of the expanded distribution parts that we talked about will annualize mid part of next year. And in general, there's some migration in terms of the market there as well that's been going on for years that we would expect to continue as well.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. And could you just talk about what's going on in the specialty channel? Have you seen any more specialty card sellers either close their doors or change their percentage of mix cards versus other products in store?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think in general, the activity that's been happening in specialty, that we've seen historically over many years, continue. Perhaps some of it accelerated during the more challenging parts of the recession in terms of door closures and while there are still door closures and they have leveled off, more of the way it has been historically than it was during the recession. And I think in general, specialty traffic has come back a bit, so that has given them a little bit more benefit as well. We're still seeing some door closures but perhaps not as much as was going on during the recession.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. Great. And then on the SG&A front, I think -- I want to clarify. Did you say that marketing was up by $10 million or marketing was $10 million?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

It is up by $10 million, increase.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Right. Okay. And that is something -- should we see that again in fourth quarter? Or was that just a timing issue that more of it was pulled into third quarter?

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think at this point, it's not a line item that we want to get into in terms of what we see in the fourth quarter even in the future years. We generally don't get into those kinds of details.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. And I guess on the merchandising freight increase, the $9 million that you talked about, is that also something that's just going to -- that's just tied to sales growth, right? So if you see less sales growth in the third quarter, we should see a lesser increase in that item.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Yes, that's generally correct. It's -- it is an ongoing activity related to volume and service of those doors or stores.

Operator

Operator

We'll go next to Breen Murphy with KeyBanc Capital Markets.

Breen Murphy

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets

I just wondered if you could run through one more time the -- kind of the dynamics driving the overall increase in working capital. I mean current assets, I apologize.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

So there are a couple of factors. Principally, the business model changed, as Zev mentioned. As we continue to grow revenues, we're seeing our inventory and receivables increase, part of which was acquired revenue. Watermark was a business we acquired this year's first quarter. So in AR, 2/3 of the increase was due to the Watermark acquisition and in inventory, about 1/3 was related to the Watermark acquisition. In addition, you have the expanded distribution representing the balance of the AR increase and about half of the inventory increase. And then the rest of the inventory increase is something we need to work on as a corporation. It's a little bit above our plan.

Breen Murphy

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets

Okay. Great. And just as it relates to the Watermark acquisition, is that something that's truly going to be onetime for the quarter? Or going forward, is that something that's going to be rationalized over the next 1 to 2 quarters?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Are you still speaking of inventory?

Breen Murphy

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets

Yes, exactly.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

No. We would anticipate that the working capital accounts associated with Watermark would continue beyond this quarter.

Breen Murphy

Analyst · KeyBanc Capital Markets

Okay. Great. And apologize if you touched on this in the prepared remarks, but can you give some color around the just overall CapEx increase in the period?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Sure. You'll see that if you look at our -- say, take our cash flow for CapEx -- that we had an increase -- on year-to-date of about $24 million. About half of that was for the systems refresh effort. Some of it was associated with the new building and land for the new building and then a little bit of it, machinery and equipment for our North American operations.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And we'll go next to John Carrington with Hound Partners.

John Carrington

Analyst · Hound Partners

So can you help us quantify the increased spending, specifically kind of what portion should we expect to persist going forward versus how much of that increased spending is temporary?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. We're not going to get into the details on the numbers. I just -- I think what we're sharing is a combination of both. And even on the areas that there may be some ongoing costs, we charged ourselves to make sure that we're getting cost savings elsewhere to help make up that.

Operator

Operator

We'll take a follow-up question from Carla Casella with JP Morgan.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

I remembered a couple of my questions. I don't have any great source for industry growth, and I'm wondering if you can talk about what you're seeing in overall industry for cards, what the growth might have been in the third quarter and where it's running year-to-date or if there's been any consultants or anything out there that you've seen that show what they expect for 2011 is?

Zev Weiss

CEO

We don't have anything on the third quarter. I think the overall card market has been steady, and we've been seeing that trend over a long period of time. And so we would expect that, that will be what we'd see for '11 and the third quarter, but we don't know that. We obviously track that, but it lags a bit.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. Because I think -- I mean hasn't the steadiness been from pricing but the volumes have been down? And I'm worried with value cards growing more that maybe we'd see the industry down, because you don't have the price growth.

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. I think in general, as you look at what's been steady, the pricing has been relatively slight. So it's not been a big trend, and so I don't think what you're seeing from an overall market perspective is a shift that's any different than what we've seen over the last 12 months, 24 months or even beyond that. I think it's been a -- the shift has been very steady.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. Great. And then just one more clarification. When you -- if you -- on the marketing spend, what type of marketing did you largely do in the quarters in the past? And is that -- has that changed year-over-year in terms of where you allocate your marketing dollars?

Zev Weiss

CEO

So we market in a number of ways, and some of our dollars are spent with our retailers, where we'll market for the season or for particular everyday activities. In some cases, we are marketing directly to consumers for our core everyday and seasonal card business. And more recently, we've been picking up some of the marketing that we've been doing on the digital side of our business. And we've been doing that for a while. We're seeing positive results as a result of that, and it's something that we're going to look to do in the future as well.

Carla Casella

Analyst · JP Morgan

Okay. Great. And then just one last question on the shift towards more value cards. Does that segment of the market -- is it more or less volatile in terms of the timing of when you know inventory returns, et cetera?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

It's very consistent with the rest of the marketplace.

Operator

Operator

We'll take our next question from Michael Schecter with Mentor.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Just a couple of quick questions. I know you don't want to get into details of the operating margin, but you're down -- the operating income's down $23 million year-over-year. And some of the stuff you called out, like marketing, sales mix, $9 million of freight, but you got to give us something on what's recurring or what's an upfront cost versus revenue not coming on board yet. Otherwise, you will -- you see, with the stock where it is, people are just annualizing it and saying, "The business has gone away."

Zev Weiss

CEO

I think, Michael, we're going to have to stick with what we said, which is it's a combination of both. And in some of the areas that we think might be more of a secular trend, the challenge of our business is going to be to find the offsets elsewhere in the business.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

I understand that, but some of this is clearly nonrecurring, unless it isn't. I mean...

Zev Weiss

CEO

We agree. It is a combination of both.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Okay. In terms of the incentives for the headquarters, is the $78 million to $93 million, is that upfront? So as you spend the $150 million to $200 million, does it come in from the government? Or is that just an over-time period?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

It's a combination of both, some of which is upfront, some of which is spread out over about a 15-year cycle, Michael. So it's both.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

So when you net down to $30 million, that's going to be at the end of the life of the headquarters as opposed to out-of-pocket up front.

Stephen J. Smith

Management

That's correct.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

And how much of out-of-pocket up front do you think it'll be?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

I don't know yet. We don't know as a corporation simply because the architectural drawing isn't yet complete.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Okay. Do you have anything left on the buyback authorization at this point?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

We have completed the share repurchase program that was authorized by our board this last quarter.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

And will you be going back to them for an additional one?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

We said in the prepared remarks that we are considering additional share purchases along with other uses of capital, so we will consider that as a possibility.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Okay. And with value changes, going back to some of the questions that were asked, will you be -- have you started to recognize revenue for all the stores that have been -- that you're incurring expenses for? Or is there still revenue to come?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

It's -- because the rollout is not yet complete, we have not yet recognized revenue from all the stores, substantially all but not all.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

And in terms of -- if you talk about a steady state, I mean, how long does it take for a store to get to what you consider normalized profitability? Is it a 12-month period?

Zev Weiss

CEO

Yes. There isn't one way to look at it. It depends on the activity that's happening in that store. Obviously, if you just do a store setup and then you don't do anything else, you have an initial cost for the setup and then you achieve the revenue and the margin going forward. Sometimes there's additional activity that needs to happen. Most of the time though, it's a store setup and then you leave it alone for a while.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Okay. Again, you've got to give us a better handle on whether -- what's recurring and what's nonrecurring or what's in between. Otherwise, there's no other way to judge this. I mean, I think what you're seeing today is people assuming that the -- your margins have collapsed permanently.

Zev Weiss

CEO

We appreciate the feedback, Michael. And we'll -- as we've done in the past in comments that have come from you and from others, we take that into account for what we share in the future, and we do appreciate the feedback on that.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And we'll go to Sean O'Malley with Wedge Capital.

Sean O'Malley

Analyst

I also have to come back to the margin question that's -- that Michael asked and Jeff and others. I think it's obvious that one of the things the market is really wrestling with here this morning is whether or not we have a new margin structure in the business. And what you're saying is well, there's some things this year that happen to be temporary, some are going to be more structural. This is all in the context of a market that's migrating towards a more value-oriented product, which you yourselves have said you've seen for a while, and you've been preparing for it. And yet, we -- in what should be probably your best quarter of the year, you have an operating margin of around 7% against the historical annual margin of 9% to 10%. And the market's saying, "Well, what -- is this a permanent new feature of the business?" And your answer is saying "Well, we have to find other ways to get costs up to get back to our historical rates of profitability." But you aren't telling us what your plans are for that, what your timeframe is for that. And without any kind of specificity on your part, I think the market is assuming the worst, and you're just not giving us a whole lot of reasons to not assume the worst. Is there some point in time where you're going to lay out a plan for, "Okay, we're -- we recognize a shift to value. We're responding to that. And over this period of time, this is how we're going to structure ourselves to be as profitable as we have been historically to how the market is shaped today."

Zev Weiss

CEO

Sean, I can only try to emphasize a couple points in how you sum that up. The first is that we don't believe that there's any additional shifts towards value product today that's different than what we've seen in terms of the historical context. It's very consistent with what we've seen over the last many years. And so there's not any major catalyst that would lead you to a different kind of a conclusion. The second is that I think we've been trying to emphasize that not all of what you're seeing in the margins are permanent. Some of that is one time. And I think your feedback of in the future, can we get more detailed about how we may offset some of what you might see in the margins today, I think is good feedback and something that we'll obviously take under consideration.

Sean O'Malley

Analyst

Okay. Well, the sooner that you can communicate that to everyone, the better. I imagine you have plans. And I think to the extent you can share those, even if they're just objectives and time period without any necessary to-dos, or you don't necessarily have the share all the to-dos but say, "This is what we want to do. This is the timeframe where we think is reasonable to achieve it, and we do have steps in place to make it happen." I think in the absence of that, if we are looking at a margin structure that is not as profitable and cash generating as it has been historically, I think as you work on the headquarters investment here, I think you really need to sharpen the pencils and say to yourselves, "Is this level of expenditure going to make sense given that we're not going to be able to fill [ph] as much cash?"

Zev Weiss

CEO

Sean, I accept that. The only thing I could share that I think is worth noting is that if you look at what we've been doing in our business for the last 5 to 10 years in terms of taking costs out, I think it ought to give you and others confidence that that is something that we've been very successful at in the past and something that we're very focused on for the future and should be successful in the future as well. It's not a new thing for us, and it's something that we know how to do and something that we intend to execute.

Sean O'Malley

Analyst

Okay. Well, like the sooner you can give us some ideas on where you're headed, on what you can achieve and when you can achieve it, I think that would really help a lot and I think help your share price out a lot, but also, you don't have to suffer questions like this every single call.

Operator

Operator

We'll take a follow-up question from Mr. Michael Schecter with Mentor.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

Just a couple things. How many shares are outstanding now at the end of the quarter? And what's the right tax rate?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

Shares outstanding, just under 40 million. Maybe one of my colleagues here can give you an exact figure.

Zev Weiss

CEO

It's about 38.5 million, Michael, and that's a basic number, not fully diluted. If you add dilution, it would be a bit higher.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

About 40 million fully diluted.

Zev Weiss

CEO

Probably 39.5 million.

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

And the tax rate?

Stephen J. Smith

Management

For the quarter or for...

Michael Schecter

Analyst · Mentor

For the year, going forward, what we should look at? What's your normal...

Zev Weiss

CEO

Right. Probably mid to upper 30% range, Michael.

Operator

Operator

It appears there are no further questions at this time. Mr. Steinberg, I'd like to turn the call back over to you for any additional or closing remarks.

Gregory M. Steinberg

Management

Thank you, Jennifer. That concludes the question-and-answer portion of today's conference call. We look forward to speaking with you again at our fiscal year 2012 fourth quarter conference call next April. We thank you for joining us this morning and wish you a happy holiday season.

Operator

Operator

That concludes today's conference. Thank you for your participation.