Earnings Labs

Claritev Corporation (CTEV)

Q1 2021 Earnings Call· Thu, May 13, 2021

$23.43

-0.28%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.
Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the MultiPlan Corporation First Quarter 2021 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speakers’ presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Shawna Gasik, AVP of Investor Relations. Thank you. Please go ahead.

Shawna Gasik

Analyst

Thank you, Casey. Good morning, and welcome to MultiPlan’s first quarter 2021 earnings call. Joining me today is Mark Tabak, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer; Dale White, President of Payor Markets; and David Redmond, Chief Financial Officer. This call is being webcast and can be accessed through the Investor Relations section of our website at www.multiplan.com. During our call, we will refer to the supplemental slide deck that is available on the Investor Relations portion of our website, along with the first quarter 2021 earnings press release issued earlier this morning. We will refer to the supplemental slide deck during our discussion this morning. Before we begin, I would like to remind you that our remarks and responses to questions may include forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Actual results may differ materially from those stated or implied by forward-looking statements due to risks and uncertainties associated with our business which are discussed in the risk factors included in our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year-ended December 31, 2020, and other documents filed or to be filed with the SEC. Any such forward-looking statements represent management’s expectations, beliefs and forecasts based on assumptions and information available as of the date of this call. While we may elect to update such forward-looking statements at some point in the future, please note that we assume no obligation to do so. Certain financial measures we will discuss on this call are non-GAAP financial measures. We believe that providing these measures help investors gain a more helpful and complete understanding of our financial results and is consistent with how management views our financial results. A reconciliation of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most comparable GAAP measure, to the extent available without unreasonable effort, is available in the earnings press release and in the slides included in the Investor Relations portion of our Company’s website. And now, I would like to turn our call over to our Chief Executive Officer, Mark Tabak. Mark?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Thank you, Shawna. Welcome, everyone. Let me join in welcoming you to our first quarter 2021 earnings call. Amid the ongoing public health crisis, we hope everyone is staying healthy and safe. I would like to thank our stockholders for their continued support. MultiPlan has a long history of delivering returns for investors as a private company, and I’m pleased to say that in our first few quarters as a public company, we’ve continued to deliver solid operating results. As this quarter’s results attest, even in the face of an accelerated pressure related to the COVID-19 pandemic, our business continues to perform. This is a testament to MultiPlan’s many competitive advantages. As detailed on page 3 of our supplemental slide deck, we start with our unique operating assets and a relentless focus on operational excellence that allows us to configure and reconfigure our resources to create lasting value for our customers, their members and ourselves. These assets underpin our leading position with our payer customers. Many of them view us as a strategic partner. We are operationally embedded in our customers’ workflow and IT processes, driving very limited customer turnover, long tenure relationships and ongoing opportunities to increase the level and scope of services we provide to them. In turn, the strength of these relationships underpin our durable financial model, which features persistent and recurring revenues, with high revenue retention rates, high EBITDA margins and attractive conversion of EBITDA to free cash flow. And finally, our financial strength supports the strategic investments we have made to grow our business and drive further value for our customers, establishing a virtuous cycle. Both revenue and EBITDA for the first quarter were in line with Q4 2020 and with the expectations we communicated earlier this year. As shown on page 4 of our…

Dale White

Analyst

Thank you, Mark, and good morning, everyone. I echo Mark’s enthusiasm about our Q1 2021 results and optimism for the year ahead as COVID starts to abate. Despite the winter surge in COVID cases and the downward pressure on elective procedures and non-emergency treatments, and despite the COVID-driven change in our claim mix to lower dollar claims, we grew revenues by 1.1% compared to the same quarter last year, our last pre-COVID quarter. We have continued to grow our claims charges volume despite pandemic conditions. As shown on page 8 of the supplemental slide deck, in Q1 2021, we processed about $29 billion in claim charges, up about 11% over Q1 2020, which had no COVID impact. At just under $5 billion in potential savings identified for clients in Q1 2021, they were nearly identical to the prior year Q1, despite a 15.5% drop in the average charge per commercial health claim. These results were possible because we continued to adapt our services to ensure we deliver value to our customers. The lower average charge per claim has been driven by the dynamics of COVID, some of which are illustrated on page 9 of our supplemental slide deck. For example, on our last earnings call, I cited a tenfold increase in testing claims between mid-2020 and year-end. Q1 2021 saw another 95% increase in COVID testing claims over Q4. COVID treatment claims were up 65% in Q1 2021 over Q4 2020. Telehealth claims remained elevated and were up 11% over the prior quarter. The average COVID test claim runs around $190. The average COVID treatment claim runs less than $700, and the average telehealth claim averages about $375. We also saw an influx of vaccine claims in Q1 growing to over 100,000 in Q1. Recall that our receipt of claims…

David Redmond

Analyst

Thank you, Dale, and good morning, everyone. I’m going to spend the majority of my time this morning discussing our guidance for 2021. But first, let me add a few comments about Q1 2021. As Mark said earlier, first quarter revenues were up 1.1% over prior year quarter, down 0.2% over Q4 2020 and in line with expectations we communicated earlier this year. Excluding the contribution from HST and Discovery, revenues were down approximately $5 million sequentially, which we believe were driven entirely by the effects of COVID and typical Q4 to Q1 seasonality in our business, as we previously communicated. As we have communicated also, our revenues lag the date medical services are provided by about 6 to 8 weeks on average. And as a result, elevated COVID case levels during November, December and January continued to affect our claim mix and our revenues throughout the first quarter. We estimate the COVID-related revenue impact in Q1 2021 was approximately $18 million to $22 million, up from our estimated impact of $12 million to $16 million that we communicated relative to Q4 2020. We estimate the COVID-related adjusted EBITDA impact of that $18 million to $22 million in Q1 2021 was approximately $16 million to $18 million. Of the $18 million to $22 million in Q1 of COVID impact, we estimate $5 million to $6 million of the impact was related to our network-based revenues. Among other dynamics, we believe this reflects a combination of COVID dynamics on our workers’ comp and auto business, which is driven by lower volumes from employees -- employers not at full capacity and less auto travel. Our PEPM revenue is also driven by unemployment trends at small to mid-sized companies and on our primary network fee-for-service business, especially related to reduced travel outside the…

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Thanks, Dave. Thanks, Dale. Before we go to Q&A, I’d like to reinforce that we’re very excited about the future. We are making solid progress against our growth strategy, the integrations of our recent acquisitions are on pace and poised to bear fruit, and we continue to execute by focusing on operational excellence. I couldn’t be prouder about how the Company has managed through COVID so far, and while the pandemic isn’t quite behind us yet, we are well positioned to drive growth and success as we move through the year. Okay, operator, let’s open up the forum for questions.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And your first question here comes from the line of Josh Raskin from Nephron Research. Please go ahead. Your line is now open.

Josh Raskin

Analyst

Hi. Thanks. Good morning, everyone. First question, just on the factors that are leading to the ramp in revenues for the remaining three quarters, sort of the annualized 1Q, it implies some growth in the guidance for the rest of the year. So, the first question would be sort of what’s the ramp there? It sounds like the COVID headwind is kind of the same throughout it. And then, Part B to that would be not seeing a similar ramp in EBITDA. So, should we just assume that’s a ramp-up in investments against the new revenue, or is the new revenue coming in at low margin? Just sort of help us with that dynamic as well.

David Redmond

Analyst

Sure. As you see the ramp -- go ahead, Mark, first.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Why don’t you speak to the initiatives in terms of selling more business to existing customers and also the addition of new customers? And then, Dave can talk about the investments in the company to fuel additional growth.

Dale White

Analyst

Sure. Absolutely, Mark. Thanks, Josh. Look, I think you know MultiPlan well enough that throughout the year, we derive additional revenue through -- through three primary sources. One is, the continued work with our existing customers on initiatives throughout the year that helped drive additional savings and value for our customers and ultimately revenue for the company. Two, it’s through the acquisition of new logos and new business, so customers that we don’t have in our suite of customers today, and that become new customers of the company. And thirdly, it’s -- I’ll say it’s more inwardly looking and it’s working on our -- it’s making and enhancing our current suite of services. And I think as you’ve heard in my comments, we have a number of initiatives underway and a number of service initiatives underway that either through machine learning or efforts that we have internally to better -- I’ll call operational initiatives that help drive monetization of claims and improve our savings rates. All of them help to fuel our growth. Dave?

David Redmond

Analyst

Sure. Hey Josh. Thank you for the questions. I think two things impact the -- first of all, on the growth rate in revenue, I think independent of HST and DHP, which we estimate to be $50 million to $55 million of revenues next year, we basically have a quarter-over-quarter growth rate of 1.5% to 2%, which annualizes into the 5% to 6% single-digit growth that we have historically had, independent of COVID. We believe that the initiatives that Dale and Mark have talked about will drive those numbers higher hopefully in subsequent years. The impact on EBITDA is primarily driven by the two acquisitions. The two acquisitions on a combined basis have an EBITDA run rate in 2021 of something in the high-20s. And DHP, which is the biggest factor, which only was included for one month in Q1, and we’ll have obviously three months in each of the other quarters, really has an EBITDA margin at the time we acquired them of something in the high teens to roughly 20%. So, that does drive a little bit of the reduction in EBITDA margins, so that as you look at where we are in the out quarters, that margin suffers a little bit. And as we said, we are investing probably $10 million to $12 million in incremental investments that we may not see a lot of revenue this year. About $5 million to $6 million of that is in IT, including artificial intelligence and machine learning, which we believe will continue to provide additional services to our customers and revenues as we develop that data. About $3 million to $4 million in our sales force, which Dale has talked about, and a few other expenses. And Josh, I think when we talk later today, we’ll walk through that in a little bit more granularity with you.

Josh Raskin

Analyst

That’s perfect. And just -- go ahead, Mark.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

We factored in $18 million to $22 million of COVID impact quarter-over-quarter and EBITDA of $16 million to $18 million, as COVID subsides in the latter half of the year, that will drive additional revenues and additional EBITDA as well, as you know.

Josh Raskin

Analyst

Yes. And then, just a second question. If you sort of think about same store results, and I know that’s tough to do, but sort of thinking about the same book of business with the same customer, are you seeing changes in sort of out-of-network usage or percentage of claims that go out of network relative to maybe pre-COVID 2019? And are you seeing better penetration of analytic services into those accounts?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Yes. Dale, do you want to comment on the customer utilization of our services and trends, and I’ll punctuate that.

Dale White

Analyst

Yes. I think it’s -- I think, Josh, you asked about the percentage of in-network utilization. I think, as I alluded to earlier, we continue to see an increase in the amount of dollars that -- through our customers. You’re right, it’s hard to predict. But, in Q1 2021, we processed about $29 billion in claim charges, which were up almost 11% over Q1 2020, which was the last pre-COVID quarter. So, we continue to deepen our relationships with our customers. We continue to look at ways to expand our relationship with our existing customers through the services, through networks, through analytics and through payment and revenue integrity. And now, with the addition of HST and Discovery, we have additional tools in our service portfolio to reach out to those same customers, and potentially new customers, and we’re delighted with some of the examples I gave you of new sales, where we’re able to -- we signed a large regional health plan to deploy later this year for prepayment payment integrity. And through Discovery, we were able to -- Discovery service is another example, we were able to -- we signed a contract for coordination of benefits and subrogation services that’s over $3 million to $4 million. So, I think we’re pleased with what we’re seeing across our customer base.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Our analytical business isn’t -- large, its footprint significantly, because not only is it now payment integrity, it’s revenue integrity and also subrogation and coordination benefits. So, we can bring a more comprehensive suite of analytical services to our payor customers and increase reliance on those capabilities, the foundation of which is the database of charging claims data that we’ve acquired over these many decades.

Dale White

Analyst

Josh, with the addition of Discovery, Mark’s right, we’ve widened our payment integrity footprint. And historically, MultiPlan and -- was a prepayment-focused company. With the addition of Discovery services, we now extend our reach into the post-payment world and broaden our suite to include things like coordination of benefits, subrogation, Medicare premium restoration, ESRD premium restoration and other services, which enrich our payment integrity and revenue integrity offering.

Operator

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Daniel Grosslight from Citi. Please go ahead. Your line is now open.

Daniel Grosslight

Analyst

I wanted to go back to the COVID impact this year of around $80 million at the midpoint. You mentioned 2Q will be similar to 1Q, which makes sense given the lag, but a little surprised that you expect the same impact in the back half of the year. Can you put a little finer point on the cadence of the impact in the back half of this year and what assumptions you’re making around testing, telehealth and higher acuity visits as we get into June and beyond? And if you could provide a breakdown by segment in the back half, that would be very helpful. Thanks.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Dave, can you walk through the analytics?

David Redmond

Analyst

Sure. As we said, Daniel, we think Q2, based on what we’ve seen so far and obviously we’re -- our way through Q2 now will be pretty similar to Q1. We don’t have enough visibility yet that we’re prepared to move our guidance numbers on Q3 and Q4. We’re hopeful and optimistic that COVID will decline in those quarters. But we wanted to give you what we’ve built into our guidance in Q3 and Q4 so that as different people have different opinions of what COVID should or should not be, we can adjust that accordingly. But, at this point in time and as a relatively new company, we want to be a little bit cautious on our guidance and make sure that we fully understand what the impact will be. The last thing we want to do is overpromise and under-deliver, and that basically drove us to the decision of using a relatively flat COVID impact across the quarters. But, what we wanted to do is totally disclose that to you, so everybody understood that -- where that’s coming from. That $20 million is basically, as I said, probably $5 million to $6 million of that is in our network business. A lot of that is workers’ comp, PEPM and our fee-for-service, what we call our travel network. Obviously, people travel less out of their primary regional area. That pretty much has continued, and we haven’t seen -- we don’t expect that to move a lot appreciably. About $9 million to $10 million of that number is in our analytics business, which is primarily driven by out-of-network claims, most particularly in anesthesia and emergency department in ASC. That continues to move a little bit, and we’re hopeful that it will move. But it’s very fragmented across the country. In Florida, those numbers seem to be moving a little bit more in the right direction than they are, say, in California or Illinois or New York. So, we’ve kind of maintained the level of where we are. And in our payment integrity business, also to a great extent, that’s driven by those out-of-network claims in those unique specialties like, ED and anesthesia and ambulatory surgery centers. So, we’ve had a lot of debate internally, and we’ve decided that we’d rather kind of flat bind that COVID impact and explain it fully to you, so we can all have that discussion when we talk individually and talk with the analysts. But, we weren’t yet prepared to move our guidance numbers, based on that, especially in the last half.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

If you look at the guidance, that $750 million to $790 million, factors in a COVID impact. If we’re being overly cautious and COVID abates more quickly, you can see there could be a meaningful increase in revenue and corresponding EBITDA, if we’re being overly cautious in the last half of the year.

Daniel Grosslight

Analyst

Yes, understood. All right. I appreciate that. And I just wanted to get your thoughts on surprise billing legislation being implemented in 2022. I know you’ve previously mentioned that there’s a lot of moving pieces here. So, do you think this can actually be implemented at the beginning of 2022? And have you started to see any changes in provider behavior and preparation for the new regulations?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Dale, why don’t we -- why don’t you step back and just do a quick summary of the surprise billing legislation as it’s been passed and then an update on rule making process where it is as of today.

Dale White

Analyst

Daniel, it’s a great question, because as hard it is to believe that we’re six months from it being implemented, it is a -- and as I think you saw from the headlines this week, there is still debate taking place at -- even at the legislative level on parts of the process. And we still don’t have -- we still don’t have interim final rules, but hopeful that -- we’re hopeful they’ll come soon, at least before July 1st. And I think the plan is to give -- to give the impact to stakeholders and opportunity to comment on those. Although I know CMS and HS is HS [ph] has been reaching out -- has reached out to folks along the way. Look, today, I think in a quick summary, I think everyone knows surprise bill protects consumers from receiving balance bills when they seek emergency care and other routine ancillary services related to emergency care, and -- or if it’s transported by an ambulance or when they receive ancillary nonemergency care. The statute has, I’ll say, critical inflection points along the way and the identification of surprise bill, calculation of, let’s call the qualified payment amount, which pretty for the most part is the insurance company’s median contracted rate. It’s the payments -- it’s then limiting that member’s co-share to what that member would have otherwise had to pay, had that provider been in in-network providers, but their liability by law is capped to that amount. There’s an opportunity for the plan at its discretion to make an offer to a provider. If that provider is unhappy with that payment, the law affords both the payor and the provider a 30-day window for payors and providers to negotiate. But at the same time, if negotiations fail, there’s a…

Mark Tabak

Analyst

I’d add three footnotes. One is that the rulemaking process has identified a lot of complexity in terms of how you administer the program. That complexity will result in increased reliance by our payor customers on MultiPlan, number one. Number two is that prior to arbitration, there is an independent dispute resolution component in negotiation. That’s what MultiPlan has historically done at a state and federal level, and we’ll continue to do that. And three, as a result of the complexity of arbitration, if in fact a negotiation cannot be consummated, again, the early indications is that much of that will be outsourced to our capability as well. So, we believe that it will have no material impact on our business and could be an enhancement over time, once the rulemaking process has been fully defined.

Dale White

Analyst

Daniel, you asked us for a comment around about it starting -- it’s supposed to start January 1, 2022, do we think there will be a delay? It’s all speculation at this point. Clearly, there’s debate taking place. Clearly, the rule-making process has to come out with an appropriate comment period. Depending on the significance of those changes, I don’t think there’ll be a delay. I think there’ll be some relief given -- again, speculation, relief given to payers or -- and/or providers as the process moves forward throughout 2022, but I would doubt seriously there’s a delay in the implementation.

Operator

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Andrew Kugler from Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead. Your line is now open.

Andrew Kugler

Analyst

Hey guys, solid quarter and guidance. Thanks for taking my questions here. Just two in mind. Looking at your second quarter guidance, even assuming similar kind of COVID impact as 1Q and then sort of sequential impact of Discovery in 2Q versus 1Q, there’s still some upside that sequentially hit the midpoint and the high end of your guidance range. So, I’m just wondering if you’re seeing that there are any new initiatives that are actually supposed to kick in, starting in 2Q that may not have been reflected in 1Q and whether there should also be a run rate for the rest of the year?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Dave, do you want to speak to guidance?

David Redmond

Analyst

Sure. I think what’s happening, Andrew, to some extent, is some initiatives that were a little bit slow with some of our customers, we have a little bit more visibility that they appear to be kicking in. As you look at kind of excluding HST and Discovery, we’re on what I’ll call base MultiPlan, we’re up about 2%, Q2 over Q1, as far as the midpoint of our guidance. And that is really customers moving a little faster in Q2 than they did in Q1. We hope that trend will continue, and we’re starting to see some of that growth. But the proof will be in the pudding. But we felt comfortable enough to move that number a little bit. If you take 2% or 1.5% quarter-over-quarter, that’s about 6% to 8% annually, and that’s what we have historically believed is our core non-COVID organic revenue growth.

Andrew Kugler

Analyst

All right. Great. Thanks. And then, you also outlined some initiatives that are in the works but haven’t taken effect yet, and you haven’t assumed revenues from those yet. Is there any way to think about what the -- I guess, for initiatives that are sort of at the end but haven’t quite kicked in yet, is there any way to think about the total revenue impact of those initiatives? And whether that would be more impactful to fiscal year 2022 or if you’re going to start seeing some of the impact from those revenue initiatives in 2H this year? Thank you.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Well, I’ll let Dale talk a little bit about initiatives. I think that a lot of those initiatives will not have a material impact, as we said on our earnings call, in 2021, although we think there’ll be some in Q3 and Q4. As we look out into 2022, obviously, we hope and are optimistic those initiatives will have double-digit impact, but we really haven’t been able to quantify exactly. And we don’t really want to talk about ‘22 at this point, given we’re still dealing with a lot of COVID right now. But, we feel very good about those initiatives. And they should generate meaningful growth in 2022.

Dale White

Analyst

Yes. I would just add, obviously, we’re in a unique position of being able to implement initiatives throughout the year with our customer base. And obviously, if you implement an initiative early in the year, you have the opportunity to have more impact. As you get further out in the year, all things being equal, that impact will be less in the current year and more in the subsequent year. So, as we -- I think I mentioned the large plan where we’re launching prepayment payment integrity later this year, the impact -- it will have some impact this year, but the lion’s share of the revenue impact will be going forward in 2022.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

The footnote to that is the objective here is that we have a number of initiatives in-flight under contract, in the process of being implemented. The goal is to get them implemented in 2021 until we get a full 12-month run in 2022 and beyond, and then add enhancements to that, either through additional IT developments or other services that we can add on to those capabilities. The best case study to-date would be the -- would be in the payment and revenue integrity where we had a footprint in payment integrity. And with the addition of Discovery, we now can do revenue integrity as well as supplement that with subrogation too once we’re already in place.

Dale White

Analyst

Yes. And as I mentioned, I think we -- operationally, throughout the year, across all of our solutions, whether that’s our network or analytics or payment integrity, we implement initiatives throughout the year to help us monetize more claims and drive additional savings and value to our customers. And as they come to fruition, whether that’s adding new analytical factors to our payment integrity program or modifying something in our analytics methodology, the good news is once those initiatives are implemented, our clients are able to take advantage of the enhancement almost right away, and we’re able to drive savings and value. And those continue to happen periodically throughout the year.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Heavily invested in machine learning, artificial intelligence to accelerate the development and application of those analytics to drive additional savings.

Operator

Operator

[Technical Difficulty] from Barclays. Please go ahead. Your line is now open.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Thanks for taking the question. Just you mentioned some cross-selling opportunities with HST, Discovery, that they’re going well and we’ve talked about a few deals that you’ve signed so far. Does your guidance include any other pipeline opportunities? And could you talk about the sizing of what’s in the pipe and timeline of moving that pipeline to revenue generation? Thanks.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Dale, do you want to talk in a little bit more granularity about the pipeline? And then, we can quantify that.

Dale White

Analyst

Yes. The pipeline is a combination of a couple of things, right? It’s looking at -- it’s cross-selling HST’s and Discovery’s services into the market. And so, it’s taking advantage of the payor relationships that we have and using that to drive distribution and sales, identify opportunities and new opportunities across our existing customer base. I mentioned HST, through the opportunities for us to sell into the third-party administrator market and through brokers and consultants, and we already have seen the effect of that with -- in a very short time with 16 new employer groups and over 13,000 lives. That will, over time, right now, over the years, as those groups are implemented, we’ll expect to see them generate, I think, around about $2 million in new revenues annually, so. And thirdly, we’re bundling our products, right? We have a -- we’re now looking at -- we’re in the early stages, but we’re bundling our products and bundling our -- all of our products together and able to reach out to our customers in a much more strategic way.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

The exciting thing for us in part is that instead of being simply a wholesaler of our services, we can now distribute services through the broker community and also direct retail to the end user and employer as well. So, there’s multiple distribution channels, which will again accelerate our growth expand revenue for the Company, and again lead in to robust margins and a high conversion to cash flow, which has historically been the nature of this company.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

And then, just on M&A, despite a bit more recent volatility in the market, we’ve generally heard the market remained a bit frothy. As you survey the space, how do you think about the Extend and Expand portion of your strategy? And will targets largely be bolt-on, similar to HST or Discovery, or would the fairly large acquisitions still be in the cards for you? Thanks.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

We’re very disciplined in terms of our M&A activity, and we’ll look at all opportunities and determine which ones would be accretive and how we could integrate them into MultiPlan’s infrastructure and take them to market as we deploy our capital to fuel supplemental growth through M&A.

Operator

Operator

[Technical Difficulty]

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Just quick ones from me. Can you just give an update on customer concentration? I’m really just curious if there’s any material changes year-over-year. And I believe the last time we talked, you noted there was a transition, at least a portion of your customers from network-based services to analytics-based services. And I was wondering if that trend continued into the first half of 2021?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

There’s been no material change from Q4 of 2020 to Q1 of 2021.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

In either regard, as it relates to network-based services to analytics-based services and customer concentration?

Dale White

Analyst

I think that the transition from network analytics has slowed. I think that kind of hit a peak over the last couple of years. A lot of that had to do with certain types of claims. ED was one of those types of claims. I think, basically, that has leveled off some, as we look at our complementary group network business. And as Mark said, our top customer percentage has not really changed over an extended period of time.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Okay. And staying with the analytics-based services. Have you seen more payors change the utilization of your offerings within their, say, moving towards markup or markdown, reference-based pricing versus using charge-based or cost-based?

Mark Tabak

Analyst

I haven’t seen any material changes in behavior. Have you?

Dale White

Analyst

You broke up on me. Say that again.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Yes. Within analytics-based services, have you seen payers change the solutions they leverage of yours, say, for example, moving towards markup or markdown from, say, charge-based and cost-based, reference-based pricing services?

Dale White

Analyst

I think, the focus -- I agree with Mark. We haven’t really seen a significant change over the past, from last year to this year in the payors’ focus on managing their costs and using cost-based methodologies, which they typically do, right? They’re using either a cost base -- in some cases, they’ll use charge-based methodologies, depending on the preference of the plan. But I haven’t really seen a material change. Now, when you get to surprise billing and arbitration, it’s going to be -- part of the arbitration process is the arbiter can’t consider the provider’s bill charge or the usual and customary charge. And at the same time, they can’t consider rates paid by Medicare, Medicaid or any other government program. So, it narrows that window of what the arbiter can use to rule during that arbitration process. They’re trying to balance it out.

Unidentified Analyst

Analyst

Okay, useful. Thank you. And last question for me as it relates to payment and revenue integrity services. Was the majority of the growth that you saw there just due to the Discovery acquisition? And then, as it relates to the acquisition, just curious how your client reception has been to the revenue offerings that Discovery brings to the division?

Dale White

Analyst

Yes. I can answer that. The growth has -- it was -- it’s not entirely through Discovery’s programs. It’s a combination of what we call the MultiPlan historical payment integrity opportunities. And in fact, one of the opportunities I mentioned in my remarks was focused on the prepayment payment integrity algorithms that MultiPlan’s program is based on. And so, that was entirely MultiPlan. Relative to Discovery, the reception has been great, and it’s been terrific. We’re very excited about the addition of Discovery’s services, particularly premium restoration and premium restoration for Medicare Advantage and ESRD. That is an opportunity. Most of what we do is to help clients manage their claims expense. In this case, this is an opportunity for Medicare Advantage plans to identify instances where the payment to them is incorrect, and to correct it and change their revenue that they receive from CMS in instances where the payment to them was incorrect. And so, that’s a revenue opportunity for the plan. And we’re very excited, and the reception by our clients has been very favorable. And obviously, we’re just getting started in terms of we owned it as of late February. But, we’re very excited about the expansion of our suite, the introduction of the customers, the wins that Discovery already has and the pipeline we’re building.

David Redmond

Analyst

To answer your question based on page 7 of the slides, where our revenue is basically $28.3 million in Q1, $27.1 million in Q4 and $26.8 million in Q1 last year. That increase is principally Discovery.

Mark Tabak

Analyst

Yes. Look, you can see very clearly that we operationalize our three-part growth strategy. You see by virtue of we’ve enhanced our existing product offerings; we’ve extended those product offerings into adjacent markets, such as Medicare Advantage is a classic case study; and we’re working very aggressively to identify service opportunities to be able to provide services to the other constituents we serve, the provider community and the patient community, consistent with our Enhance, Extend and Expand strategy we articulated previously. End of Q&A:

Operator

Operator

[Technical Difficulty] today’s conference call. Thank you for participating.