Earnings Labs

Donegal Group Inc. (DGICB)

Q3 2012 Earnings Call· Fri, Oct 26, 2012

$19.32

-2.23%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+0.00%

1 Week

-4.12%

1 Month

+3.09%

vs S&P

+2.53%

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good morning. My name is Morris, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Donegal Group Inc. Q3 2012 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Thank you. Mr. Jeff Miller, you may now begin your conference.

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

Thank you. Good morning everyone, and welcome to the Donegal Group conference call for the third quarter ended September 30, 2012. I'm Jeff Miller, CFO, and I will begin today's call with commentary on the quarterly financial results. Don Nikolaus, President and CEO, will then provide additional comments on the quarter and give a business update. You should be aware that certain statements made in our news release and in this conference call are forward-looking in nature and involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Please refer to our news release for more information about forward-looking statements. Further information on risk factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in the forward-looking statements is available in the report on Form 10-K that we submit to the SEC. You can find a copy of our 2011 Form 10-K in the Investors section of our website under the SEC Filings link. Further, reconciliation of non-GAAP information, as required by SEC Regulation G, was provided in our news release, which is also available in the Investors section of our website. We are very pleased to be able to report significant improvement in our third quarter results. Net income increased to $6.8 million from $820,000 in last year's third quarter, and operating income increased to $6 million from an operating loss of $800,000 last year. I'll discuss a number of factors that contributed to the improved results. First, we continue to benefit from premium and rate increases and an ongoing emphasis on growth in our commercial lines of business. We've discussed personalized rate actions in previous calls, and we are clearly benefiting from those rate increases and continue to file for additional increases. We're also experiencing substantial improvement in our commercial renewal premium increases, averaging between 7% and 8% over…

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Thank you, Jeff. And good morning to everyone, and welcome to our third quarter earnings call. Jeff has done a very fine job of doing a very good summary of the details of the third quarter. What I would like to do is to do just a little bit of a recap and then provide some input as to what we believe the reasons are for the significant improvement. The earnings per share that has been reported is $0.27 per share versus $0.03 per share in the prior year. Our statutory combined ratio came in at 97.6% versus 110.6% in 2011. Revenues were up 9.5% over the prior quarter. And a very interesting statistic, our commercial combined ratio for the third quarter was 91.4%, which we believe evidence very strong profitability on the business that we are writing commercially. Net premiums written are up 11.3. Our book value as $15.74 versus $15.01 at the end of 2011. Needless to say, we're pleased with this turn around, and we think that the trend is important. And we believe that, that's what we are experiencing and seeing here. Let's chat about some of the significant reasons for the improvement in the financial results. From a rate adequacy and rate premium increases we continue to file throughout 2012, rate increases in homeowners between 8% and 12%, depending upon the specific state. We are now working on the rate indications and filings for the beginning of 2013. We are seeing the same kind of trend. In private passenger automobile, where we have in 2012 and are looking to continue that with the applicable states that have not received that input, that we will be increasing private passenger automobile rates depending upon the state, somewhere between 4% and 7%. The overall market for commercial lines,…

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

I will ask Morris to open the line for questions. We'll be glad to respond to any questions that you might have.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And we do have a question from Brett Shirreffs.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

A couple of questions here. First, you mentioned the success in Michigan. Just wondering as we approach the end of the year, what you're thinking about doing with that, that quarter share for next year?

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Well, as a matter of fact, that's a topic that is currently under discussion. We have not arrived at a decision about that. But if you look at last year, you will see that we reduced it. And that is certainly one of the significant possibilities here. But at this point, we have not made that decision or what that percentage would be.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

Okay. And in the release, you mentioned that frequency was lower in casualty lines. Is there any sense as to why that's happening? Or anything you can provide there.

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

Well, we've seen some fluctuations in frequency in the casualty lines. If you look back to 2010, we would have had very similar statistics in the third quarter. So it's hard to say why losses do not occur. Easier to look at why losses might have occurred. But in the current quarter, we clearly saw a decrease in the number of reported claims across the various casualty lines of business, and it would be more consistent with what we saw in the 2010 year. So we don't think there's anything necessarily unusual about it. It's just one of those types of statistics that can fluctuate from quarter to quarter.

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Now from a strictly underwriting perspective, Brett, we would like to think that some of that is the result of underwriting and focusing on making sure that we have the best business on the books. But we certainly aren't able to significantly measure that at this point.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

Okay. We'll caulk it up to better risk selection. And you mentioned the rate increase in personal lines. Is the growth there primarily from rate increases? Or how has policy count been trending?

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Policy count is fairly flat. So in personal lines, it's primarily rate increases.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

Okay. And how about the policy count in commercial lines, is that up pretty significantly?

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Policy count in commercial lines is up. I would note that I would say significantly keeping in mind that we generally measure premium increases more in commercial lines because you could have one policy that has a large premium and the next policy has a very small premium. But it's up. Jeff, do you have any statistics there?

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

I'm doing the math in my head. But it's up 8% or so up from a year ago.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

And just lastly, I guess I saw some continued buyback this quarter. The stock is sold off a little bit last few weeks and trading below where you guys bought back during the third quarter. Any tendency to continue that now that the share price is a little bit lower?

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Well, as historically, we have bought shares, and we would anticipate continuing to do that at appropriate times and at appropriate levels.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions]

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

While we're waiting for any additional questions, we probably should discuss briefly the potential of Hurricane Sandy that's coming up at the coastline. And obviously, we're monitoring that with interest. The potential impact, if you're looking at what could a storm such as that hurricane do to our financial results, we do have reinsurance limits that would limit the impact to anywhere from $3 million to, if it includes all of our subsidiaries, somewhere in the $4.5 million range. We would remind you that last fourth quarter 2011, we had some significant development from storms that have occurred earlier in the year. So our results in the fourth quarter 2011 were significantly impacted by hurricanes and storms that had occurred earlier in 2011. So we are hopeful that our fourth quarter 2012 results will outperform what we reported in the fourth quarter of 2011. And of course, we're most hopeful that Hurricane Sandy just goes out to sea. But we're closely monitoring that and hope that anyone in harm's way will be safe.

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

And Jeff, is it fair to say that 2012 storms and events anywhere in the third quarter, second quarter and first quarter, that we would not anticipate any development in the fourth quarter of any of those events. That's there.

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

That is correct because in the third and the fourth quarter 2011, we were dealing with the 5 different events that had exceeded our retentions. We don't have anything like that in 2011. Only one event has exceeded our external retention. And so we have plenty of capacity available on our reinsurance.

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

And also, we're not weather forecasters. Hopefully, it will go out to sea or the impact will be minor. But if it does impact the East Coast, what Jeff has described is the impact on us financially will not be significant.

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

Morris, do we have another follow-up question?

Operator

Operator

We do have a follow-up question from Brett Shirreffs.

Brett Shirreffs

Analyst

Just wondering if you could remind us what the impact of Hurricane Irene was last year?

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

Hurricane Irene did impact all of our subsidiaries in the mid-Atlantic. So there would have been a fairly significant impact. Because of the fact that we exceeded our reinsurance capacity, it had a more significant impact than what we would normally have expected. I don't have exact numbers, but I would say that there was probably somewhere in the $6 million range that Hurricane Irene would have impacted our results. So we would expect that if Sandy would hit the same track that Irene did, we would have a lesser impact because of the current reinsurance capacity that we have.

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

And when Jeff refers to exceeded reinsurers, he is talking about the first layer of our cat layers. Because of all the number of events in 2011, we would have used up the first layer. And therefore, when Irene hit, there wasn't much left in terms of that first layer cover to provide protection. But as with Sandy, we don't have any of those issues, and it's simply straightforward mathematical that even if it was a significant event, it should not cause our earnings a loss of $4 million to $4.5 million.

Operator

Operator

And there are no further questions in the queue.

Jeffrey Miller

Analyst

Okay. Well, we thank everyone for listening in and wish you a good day.

Donald Nikolaus

Analyst

Thank you, everybody. We appreciate your participation.

Operator

Operator

Thank you for participating in today's conference call. You may now disconnect.