David Berges
Analyst · Goldman Sachs
Well, I can you a couple of pieces, but as always, there are a couple of unknowns. I'll give you some thoughts on it, but you kind of need to pick it, as do we. In the case of regional and business jets, we're kind of at a run rate that looks to be less than 120, and I don't know where that's going, but I'd be real surprised if that comes back any time soon. So, I don't see that getting stronger. In fact, I still think it could drift a little further. It's important, if you're trying to model us, that you go back and look at when the comps start to change in each of these markets. In the case of our other commercial, the drop really was this quarter -- a little bit last quarter, pretty serious this quarter. Whereas commercial aerospace, we had Boeing strike in the fourth quarter of last year, Airbus started to trend down in the fourth quarter of last year, and then inventory destocking hit us pretty hard in both the first and second quarter this year. So we're approaching a bit of a lapping in commercial aerospace. Furthermore, this inventory destocking -- I'd have been a little uncomfortable talking about it because it's so hard to quantify it. But having seen that almost every other aerospace supplier said the same thing and had numbers that look similar, I guess one must presume that it's a fact. We did try to find a way to just do some back of the envelope calculations that you could do yourself, if you haven't already. If we look at our model of what we would expect to ship in a steady state mode, with the Boeing and Airbus current projected line rates -- if you did that math, you'd say that we were over- shipping by, in the neighborhood of 10% the second half of last year. That is, we were anticipating an Airbus step up, and suppliers were calling for more materials, and the 787 was on whatever track it was on. And, conversely, the first half of this year, or at least the second quarter, it looks to be in the neighborhood of 10% below what is the steady state run rate. So, if that crude math gives you any sort of calibration, it would say -- and again, I am talking about the large commercial jets. So our large commercial jets, excluding the other commercial aerospace. If line rates stay where people say they're going to be, we would expect that we are under shipping by about 10%, and we ought to be able to get some of that back. And I would think and hope that we'd start seeing some of that in the fourth quarter. Now, we've got a 777 line rate reduction, going from seven a month to five a month next summer. We are typically six months ahead, so that'd be a little bit of a hurt starting in January. On the other hand, one has to think that the A380 and 787 deliveries do start to at least show up on the radar, and could offset that. So I am hopeful that, unless there are further line rate reductions, that we are looking at the bottom of the large commercial jet sales. Now, I know a lot of you think that build rates are going down, but I remind you that if they do go down next year, it's likely to be in the A320, 737 size, despite both Boeing and Airbus insisting that they think that looks pretty good for next year. And the decline there is much less painful to us than delays on new programs. So that's sort of how I look at commercial aerospace right now. And then wind energy is really about credit markets and how soon the recovery goes. I think the recovery in the U.S. could go pretty quickly, assuming financing is there. And I think we'd start seeing growth again in the U.S. Our customer, of course, has better share in Europe, so we're keeping a close eye on Europe. Europe seems to be struggling with government aggressiveness and financing. So there the step down clearly took place this quarter. The third quarter last year, you might recall, was a very strong quarter; it was the strongest of the year, despite being in Europe, on wind. So I'm expecting wind will be a little disappointing for a number of quarters. But it's really credit market dependant. So, I guess a long-winded answer. The third quarter, as we talked about -- plant shutdowns, inventory correction, wind energy. We expect not a very pretty third quarter. And I really think the fourth quarter, depending on what happens with wind, could look a little bit like this quarter.