Earnings Labs

NMI Holdings, Inc. (NMIH)

Q2 2022 Earnings Call· Tue, Aug 2, 2022

$41.47

-0.30%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

+11.97%

1 Week

+20.81%

1 Month

+8.78%

vs S&P

Transcript

Operator

Operator

Good day, and welcome to the NMI Holdings, Inc. Second Quarter 2022 Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in a listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mr. John Swenson. Please go ahead, sir.

John Swenson

Analyst

Thank you, operator, good afternoon, and welcome to the 2022 second quarter conference call for National MI. I'm John Swenson, Vice President of Investor Relations and Treasury. Joining us on the call today are Brad Shuster, Executive Chairman; Adam Pollitzer, President and Chief Executive Officer; Ravi Mallela, Chief Financial Officer; and Julie Norberg, our Chief Accounting Officer. Financial results for the quarter were released after the close today. The press release may be accessed on NMI's website located at nationalmi.com under the Investors tab. During the course of this call, we may make comments about our expectations for the future. Actual results could differ materially from those contained in these forward-looking statements. Additional information about the factors that could cause actual results or trends to differ materially from those discussed on the call can be found on our website or through our regulatory filings with the SEC. If and to the extent, the Company makes forward-looking statements, we do not undertake any obligation to update those statements in the future in light of subsequent developments. Further, no one should rely on the fact that the guidance of such statements is current at any time other than the time of this call. Also note that on this call, we refer to certain non-GAAP measures. In today's press release, and on our website, we have provided a reconciliation of these measures to the most comparable measures under GAAP. Now, I'll turn the call over to Brad.

Brad Shuster

Analyst

Thank you, John, and good afternoon, everyone. We had a terrific second quarter with strong operating performance, significant growth in our insured portfolio, and record financial results. During today's call, as we always do, we'll share with you the details behind our numbers in the implications for the periods ahead. I'd like to focus, however, on the macroeconomic environment. I've been in this business for almost 30 years. I have seen a number of economic cycles over that time. And importantly, I've seen how the mortgage insurance industry overall and National MI specifically, have learned from and been transformed by past experience. We do see an emerging set of macro headwinds. However, we do not expect the economy or the housing market to deteriorate as they did in the financial crisis. For more than a decade now, underwriting standards have been disciplined and responsible across the mortgage market. Regulatory guard rails have been enacted and the toolkit to assist borrowers through stress has grown meaningfully. Our borrowers today have a strong credit profile, significant equity position in their homes given the recent run of house price appreciation, and benefit from record low 30-year fixed-rate mortgages with manageable debt service obligations. From the start, we are focused on building National MI in a durable risk responsible manner. We've worked hard to establish a comprehensive credit risk management framework, and in doing so, we have built the highest quality insured portfolio in the MI industry, and have secured comprehensive reinsurance protection for nearly the entirety of our book. I'm confident in our ability to perform across all market cycles. We will continue to invest in our employees, support our customers and their borrowers, and deliver for our shareholders. No matter how the economy develops. Shifting to Washington matters. In early June, the…

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Thank you, Brad, and good afternoon, everyone. National MI continued to outperform in the second quarter, delivering significant new business production, strong growth in our high-quality insured portfolio, continued success in the reinsurance market, and record results across every key financial metric. We generated $16.6 billion of NIW volume and ended the quarter with a record $168.6 billion of high-quality, high-performing Insurance in force. We achieved a record GAAP net income of $75.4 million or $0.86 per diluted share and a record adjusted net income of $74.3 million, also $0.86 per diluted share. GAAP return on equity for the quarter was 19.7% and adjusted ROE was 19.4%. During the quarter, we also entered into a new quota share reinsurance agreement securing incremental risk protection for a season portion of our in-force portfolio. The transaction builds upon the broad success that we've had in the risk transfer markets to date and provides us with approximately $150 million of incremental PMIERs funding capacity at an attractive cost of capital. Overall, we had an exceptionally strong quarter, and are optimistic as we progress into the second half. Our lenders and their borrowers continue to rely on us for critical down payment support, purchase demand remains strong, and we see a significant opportunity to continue writing high-quality, high return, high-value, new business. We expect our persistency will continue to improve meaningfully driving sustained growth in our in-force book and a further increase in the embedded value of our insured portfolio. And our credit experience continues to trend in a favorable direction with the performance data from our portfolio, remaining resoundingly strong. Taken together, we see a clear opportunity for continued outperformance. We do, however, also see increased risk in the macro environment. Rising rates and the record run of house price appreciation have strained…

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

Thank you, Adam. We delivered record financial results in the second quarter with strong new business volume, significant growth in our insured portfolio, continued resiliency in our credit performance, and expense efficiency driving record profitability. Net premiums earned were a record $120.9 million, adjusted net income was a record $74.3 million or $0.86 per diluted share, and adjusted return on equity was 19.4%. We generated $16.6 billion of NIW in the second quarter up 17% from the first quarter. Purchase NIW was $16.2 billion during the quarter. Primary insurance in force grew to $168.6 billion, up 6% from the end of the first quarter and up 23%, compared to the second quarter of 2021. 12-month persistency in our primary portfolio improved again reaching 76% compared to 71.5% in the first quarter. We expect persistency will continue to improve meaningfully as we progress through the year, a real positive that will help drive sustained portfolio growth and embedded value gains in the second half. Net premiums earned in the second quarter were $120.9 million compared to $116.5 million in the first quarter. We earned $2.2 million from the cancellation of single premium policies in the second quarter compared to $2.9 million in the first quarter. Reported yield for the second quarter was 30 basis points unchanged from the first quarter. Investment income was $10.9 million in the second quarter compared to $10.2 million in the first quarter. Underwriting and operating expenses were $30.7 million in the second quarter compared to $32.9 million in the first quarter. Our expense ratio was a record low of 25.4% in the quarter highlighting the significant operating leverage embedded in our business and the success we have achieved in efficiently managing our cost base as we have scaled our insured portfolio. We have long signaled our…

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Thank you, Ravi. Overall, we had a terrific quarter with significant new business production, increasing persistency, and growth in our high quality and short portfolio driving record revenue, and favorable credit performance and expense discipline driving record profitability and strong returns. We're optimistic about the opportunity we have to continue to outperform in the second half. Stepping back, this is an interesting time, one where the strength of our current performance and near-term outlook stands in contrast to prevailing economic themes. It's important to focus on our current results if they highlight the value of our strategy and long-term potential, while at the same time it's equally important to acknowledge and plan for potential macroeconomic outcomes. We've long been successful managing National MI with discipline and a focus on through-the-cycle performance and believe we're well-positioned to continue to serve our customers and their borrowers, invest in our employees and their success, drive growth in our high-quality and short portfolio, and deliver strong performance for our shareholders. Thank you for joining us today. I'll now ask the operator to come back on. So, we can take your questions.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And the first question will come from Mark Devries with Barclays. Please go ahead.

Mark Devries

Analyst

Yes, thanks. I wanted to drill down a little more on some of the different moving pieces, you highlighted some of the comments around the premium. It sounds like there have been some selective price increases, but also like at least the latest QSR is going to weigh on premiums in the near term. How should we think about kind of the net impact on the average premium over the next couple of quarters?

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

Sure. Maybe I'll start, Mark, by just saying that our premium yield in Q2 was 30 basis points, and it was flat. And just really thinking about the mechanics for Q2, we had the impact of the new XOL, and we had a little bit of a decline in our cancellation earnings in the quarter, and that's summed up to about a basis point impact on yield. And that was offset really by sort of the amortization of the cost of the QSRs that we have, and the ILN that we have in place and so we ended up at 30 basis points sort of there. Just touch on sort of on the moving parts with respect to the premium yield for Q3, the impact of the season QSR, we've talked about it in our scripted remarks, it's more efficient and it's a fantastic deal for us, but it definitely impacts us in a different way than the ILNs. With the season QSR, 35% of our ceded premiums come back in the form of ceded commissions, and that impacts our expense line. And with ILN, all of the ceded premiums come back as net premiums earned. And so there is an impact on the premium yield the season QSR, it's more efficient and it certainly provides us benefits in some of those benefits flow through experience and impact our premium yield. So, in Q3, we estimate the impact of the season QSRs having about 1.5 basis points on net yield. And maybe just to balance these comments, I would just say the hardening environment, I think could provide us with some benefit, but that's really on new production, and that's been a really depend a lot on the risk mix, how NIW involves, kind of how cancellation earnings trend, I think we're seeing them trend down, we'll probably see them to continue to trend down. And I think, also an offset to that would be the decline in the amortization of the costs of our ILN and XOLs, and those are sort of the moving parts with respect to how we think about Q3 and premium yield.

Mark Devries

Analyst

Okay, that's helpful. And then just turning to your operating expenses, is there anything to call out that really drove will affect some pretty significant operating leverage in the quarter? And furthermore, I guess you guys are now kind of at your long-term guidance, but still exhibiting pretty significant growth and operating leverage. Any color on kind of where we think that might trend.

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

I'll talk a little bit about just what happened in the quarter, and give you a little bit about how we think about the trend. First, I'll just say, we're very proud of achieving our long-run goal of targeting low to mid-'20s with our record low expense ratio of 25.4% in the quarter. And I just say in terms of the moving parts with respect to Q1, our IT cost declined, we've talked in the past about our TCS relationship. We're in year two of that relationship, and frankly, our TCS cost declined. We had a sort of an annual step down in costs and we picked up sort of a big portion of that here in Q1 about $1 million. And I think the rest of the difference between Q1 and Q2, we're really focused on the difference between Q1 and Q2 and really Q1 came in with typically higher payroll costs with respect to higher 401(k) cost and a FICO reset, and if you combine those two, the differences and payroll costs and the TCS benefit we picked up in Q2, that's really what drove the difference between Q1 and Q2. But when we look forward, I think you know we're always very focused on being efficient with 246 employees, we have the smallest footprint in the industry by far, and I would just say we probably expect some growth in our gross expenses, but we're going to continue to invest in our people, our systems, and in risk management, and I think the other part to really factor in is the impact of the season QSR, and so that 35% ceding commission is going to be an offset to OpEx in the future. And I just say net-net of our -- with our investments in the impact of the season QSR, we're probably going to see a modest benefit going forward.

Operator

Operator

And the next question will be from Doug Harter from Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.

John Kilichowski

Analyst

This is John Kilichowski on for Doug. Just one question from me. What was the driver behind the positive reserve development this quarter? And what's your outlook going forward for reserves and curious for the rest of 2022?

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

Yes, I mean, we reported a $3 million net claims benefit in the quarter. I just say that we're continuing to see progress with respect to our default population, our default rate declined to 77 basis points in the quarter, down from 99 basis points in Q1. And just the total number of defaults has declined, we're down to 4,271 this quarter. And I'd just say the cure activity has been relatively strong. Cure activity in Q2 was just slightly higher than what we saw in Q1. So, that's about 2000 cures. Look, I mean it's pretty, pretty, pretty strong results with respect to how we've been performing. I would just say that when we combine those pieces together, and we think about the cure activity in the pre-COVID default population, the fact that defaults have declined quarter-over-quarter, and cure rates have been relatively stable. We -- that's what drove our thought process with respect to Q2.

Operator

Operator

And the next question will be from Rick Shane from JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

Rick Shane

Analyst

Hi guys, thanks for taking my questions this afternoon. Look, as we move through earning season and we think about different things that we've heard within our broader coverage, every once in a while something idiosyncratic comes up in terms of either pocket of strength or weakness. And again, I realize that, what's going on from a credit perspective, it's pretty difficult to extrapolate because the credit performance is so good, but is there anything that you're seeing that you would call it out either on a positive or negative side, that's a little bit surprising, a GEO where you're seeing some HPA something interesting that you're seeing either positive or negative within the portfolio?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes. Hey, Rick, I'll -- It is an interesting time, right? You referenced idiosyncratic outcomes. So, I would say, there is so much of the current data that we look at both internally and externally is telling quite a positive story, but there obviously emerging risks that we're all tuned to that we hear about every day that we see in other ways that are emerging in a cloud of the go-forward view. When we look at it today, the job market is still healthy, consumer spending remains strong, household balance sheets are in better shape than they were before the pandemic, and most importantly, our credit performance continues to trend in a really favorable direction. We don't have a crystal ball, but when we think about what our data is telling us today versus what the emerging themes are, we do think that there is a higher likelihood that growth will slow rather than accelerate that unemployment will increase from here as opposed to decreasing further and that consumer fundamentals will soften as opposed to strengthening. And all of that will have some bearing, on our business, it will have some bearing, on where volume trends, it will have some bearing, on house price performance, on credit performance, for borrowers across the mortgage spectrum, but there's really nothing when we try to look, we look for, take out the magnifying glass and try to identify where might we be seeing the earliest signs of a shift. We look at the emerging population of borrowers who may have missed one payment but not missed enough payments or been in default status for long enough to progress into a technical default definition. We look at the rate of early payment defaults, our borrowers who come into the market within the last 12 months facing an undue amount of stress, and there is nothing in even those areas where we would typically look for an early indication that signals a turn is on the horizon. Instead, what we're really keying off of there, it's just the general headline, the general macro sentiment that obviously has been emerging over the last several months.

Rick Shane

Analyst

Hi, Adam, I really appreciate the sincerity with which you approach that question. We're wrestling with the exact same stuff, so I appreciate the answer.

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Great, thanks, Rick.

Operator

Operator

The next question will be from Bose George from KBW. Please go ahead.

Bose George

Analyst

Yes, good afternoon. Just one more follow-up on the expenses. I mean now that you're at the 25% that you're going to targeted. As it continues to grow, could we see that closer to 20% that we see from some of the larger peers?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Well, look, we mentioned low to mid-'20s as long-term goals. We certainly have a goal, continuing to manage our business with as much efficiency as possible, if we're successful in doing that, which we expect to be and we continue to grow our insurance in force. We will likely see some continued improvement in our expense ratio over the long term. Can't give you guidance though on the timeline over which that will emerge.

Bose George

Analyst

Okay, that's great, thanks. Actually, I didn't know if you gave this, but what's the cash at the holding company?

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

Cash and investments at the holding company are $114 million.

Bose George

Analyst

Okay, great, thanks. And then actually, just one on the -- what's the duration of your investment portfolio just when I think about the AOCI kind of rolling back in overtime?

Ravi Mallela

Analyst

At Q2, it was 4.3.

Operator

Operator

The next question will be from Mark Hughes from Truist. Please go ahead.

Mark Hughes

Analyst

Yes, thanks, good afternoon. I wonder if you can make a general comment with interest rates up and presumably housing prices up start to -- but still impact of the higher housing is on the need for private mortgage insurance. Are you seeing that this is higher interest rates in their way, increasing demand for your product?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes, it's a good question, Mark. What I would say is the need for our support is much more driven by down payment support than it is for what the monthly carrying cost of the home will be. So, movements in interest rates themselves don't necessarily impact the market opportunity or the penetration. On the purchase side, certainly they impact the refinancing opportunity because obviously, borrowers may not find as much value in pursuing the refinancing transaction. If the rise of house prices over the last several years that's increased the need for our support and we have been delighted to be able to really step in and provide borrowers with the support they need and help them gain access to housing. But it's not interest rates, it's house prices driving increased loan balances, obviously, additional need for down payment dollars upfront, that really increases the opportunity for us.

Mark Hughes

Analyst

Understood. Then thinking about the current macro environment you laid out how the -- when you look at some of these broader factors could have an impact on the losses forward. How did the reinsurers look at it? Obviously, your new transaction is pretty attractive thing. Is that attractive pricing, a function of the good position of your portfolio or would you say the reinsurers at this point are not putting too much concern into these macro issues?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes, it's a good question, Look, what I'd say is right now, overall, the reinsurance market and our ability to access attractive funding with the risk protection characteristics that we think are appropriate to help us manage our obligation is there. The market is open, it's open to us in size, and it's open on favorable terms. But our reinsurers are quite smart they obviously monitor what's happening in the environment as well. We have long-term relationships with them, they understand how we manage our business, they understand that we're always on our front foot with respect to risk and managing our flows. And I think that is -- that's something that helps us achieve favorable outcomes in the reinsurance market that is certainly focused on it, but in just the same way that we are still in the market, providing support for our customers and their borrowers, we are their customers and they are in the market continuing to provide support for us even as the macro environment evolves.

Operator

Operator

The next question will be from Ryan Gilbert from BTIG. Please go ahead.

Ryan Gilbert

Analyst

Hi, thanks, and good evening everybody. I was hoping to get your updated thoughts on or quantification of where you think persistency can go and maybe quantify or expand on what a meaningful improvement in persistency means.

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Okay, good. I mean, Ryan, I think we mentioned on the call that our -- as of Q2, our persistency was at 76%, it's up from 71.5% in Q1. And certainly, we think we're on a trend to 80% given the current rate environment. And certainly, that provides a tremendous amount of value to us. It extends the life of many of our policies, which adds to the embedded value in our portfolio. And we see that as a real positive for us as an organization. Assuming that our strong credit performance continues to trend the way it has, it's going to build embedded value in our portfolio over time and it's going to be a real positive for us.

Ryan Gilbert

Analyst

Okay. Second question on home price appreciation. I mean, we can look at the home price indices that are published with the lag. I would love to get your updated thoughts or your view on how HPA trended throughout the quarter. And maybe into July, if you have any visibility into like where spot prices are?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes, look what I'd say is, generally speaking, we do expect that the pace of house price appreciation. One has slowed, and then it will continue to slow, and that we may begin to see some modest declines, we haven't seen that yet, but some modest declines across certain markets, we really do look at it though on a market-by-market basis, in Rate GPS, we individually assess and price for 950 or so discrete MSAs. And so, I can't give you a complete rundown because every market will have its own rhythm, it is an interesting one though where much of what we've experienced collectively over the last few years has been national in scope. Right. We've had broad swings from an employment standpoint right with broad strength nationally, we've had broad house price appreciation nationally, with obviously some differentiation market-by-market, but we think that -- what we think we'll see emerge going forward though is a much more differentiated outcome on a market-by-market basis. And so, that we're monitoring, but we look at it across nearly 1,000 different MSAs nationally when we consider where credit is going and how we need to price for or manage the risk as a result.

Ryan Gilbert

Analyst

Got it. And just to follow up on that. In the geographies where you expect home price appreciation to decline or are there is an increased probability that it might, what do you see as the catalyst for home prices to move lower? I think we generally think of home prices is sticky downward.

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes, look, it's a couple of things. When we look at individual markets, we're looking at, one, where was there the most significant house price appreciation over the last few years? Right. Higher prices don't necessarily mean that higher prices from a few years ago, don't necessarily mean that things will fall in the future, but it's a place for us to start looking, but then we unpack that, right? The housing market is a market like all others that's driven by supply-demand dynamics. And so, we look what are those markets that have seen the most significant house price appreciation that has also seen the most significant supply build in recent period, either because they are markets where there is a much larger concentration of new construction where new home sales have accounted for a larger and larger percentage of overall home sales than the rest of the country, or where inventory of existing homes is building, and we pair that with some other data that we look at to try to get a sense for, and we're on top of that, do we see a greater disconnect from income levels, local economic opportunity, and affordability. And so, it's a bit of a mosaic that we look at, we're trying to assess where we will see those modest declines. Again, we look at 950 or so MSAs, and we do this on a constant continuous basis. There are some one-third in the headlines like Boise, is an area that's constantly referred to and we do see some of these dynamics emerging there. But there are other areas in the Mountain West there are areas through Texas where we look at the same dynamics as well.

Operator

Operator

[Operator Instructions] And the next question will come from Bill Dezellem with Tieton Capital. Please go ahead.

Bill Dezellem

Analyst

Thank you, that's Tieton Capital. Adam, in your comments, in the press release, you referenced a significant new business production. Would you dive into that in a bit more detail and discuss what that's referring to? And maybe how that may or may not relate to things that Rich mentioned in the analyst meeting a year ago?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Sure, simplistically when we refer to significant new business production what we're focusing on is the NIW that we generated in the period. So, we wrote $16.6 billion of high quality, high return, high value, new business in the quarter. And for us, that's up a little over 17% compared to what we achieved in the first quarter. So, we feel terrific about what we were able to achieve from a customer support standpoint where we were able to support borrowers and ultimately what allowed us to drive from an NIW standpoint.

Bill Dezellem

Analyst

And to what degree, do you see that 17% increase a function of new lenders that you were working with and your efforts on that front?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Yes, it's a good question. We do talk about this a lot, but we didn't give the stat, I'll give it -- we give it and then pass. We activated 35 new lender customers in the quarter, which is sort of -- that's consistent with where we've been, there's still some white space for us for large moving accounts, which were included in there, but in a particular quarter, the accounts that we activate, the new customers that we activate have very, very little impact on the NIW that they -- that we generate rather those new accounts that we bring on, have the potential over time to help drive future NIW opportunity and NIW growth.

Operator

Operator

The next question will be from Geoffrey Dunn from Dowling Partners. Please go ahead.

Geoffrey Dunn

Analyst

Thanks. Can you quantify the reserve strengthening actions you took in the quarter? What portion of the $8.7 million current period provision is related to that?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Geoff, if you look at it, there is a lot that goes into it. But ultimately, if you simply try to isolate what's the average reserve that we established for each new default it was roughly double this quarter compared to what it was last quarter.

Geoffrey Dunn

Analyst

Okay. So this -- so I want to make sure I understand this, but this was on the entire non-COVID notice book. Correct?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

No. So the new defaults that emerged, the 1069 new defaults that emerged in the second quarter, we established roughly a 2x reserve for each of those NODs as we had on the new defaults that emerged for the first time in the first quarter of 2022.

Geoffrey Dunn

Analyst

Okay. And is that claim rate adjustment or severity adjustment or combo thereof?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

It's a combination of both.

Geoffrey Dunn

Analyst

Okay. And then I wanted to go back to the QSR, make sure I'm understanding this, I believe you called 17 deal in the first quarter, it sounds like you called '20-1 in the second quarter. So, when you referenced $1.6 million kind of cost going away, that was not the Q2 run rate. Correct?

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

That's correct. So, we called the 17 deal on March 25, we called the 2020 deal on April 25, what we referenced was the last quarter in which those deals were outstanding for the full duration of the quarter. The combined cost was $1.6 million. So, that would be the fourth quarter for ILN -- that the 2017 deal and it would be the first quarter for -- last quarter for the 2020 deal.

Operator

Operator

Again, thank you very much. Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes our question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to management for any closing remarks.

Adam Pollitzer

Analyst

Thank you, again for joining us. We'll be attending the Barclays Financial Services Conference in New York on September 13, and participating in the Zelman virtual Housing Summit on September 21. We look forward to speaking with you again soon.

Operator

Operator

And thank you very much. The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.