Earnings Labs

XP Inc. (XP)

Q3 2024 Earnings Call· Tue, Nov 19, 2024

$19.35

-1.15%

Key Takeaways · AI generated
AI summary not yet generated for this transcript. Generation in progress for older transcripts; check back soon, or browse the full transcript below.

Same-Day

-6.06%

1 Week

-3.90%

1 Month

-26.98%

vs S&P

-27.12%

Transcript

Thiago Maffra

Management

[Abrupt Start] …posting a 12% increase year-over-year. As we will see during the presentation, it's important to mention that it was another consistent quarter regarding net inflows, aligned with our levers and our capacity to adapt becoming more relevant in fixed-income in the current scenario. We also increased our total number of advisors, reaching 18,400, growing 9% year-over-year, and continued to expand our active client base marking BRL4.7 million, increasing 6% year-over-year. During the nine months 2024, gross revenues grew 17% year-over-year, reaching BRL13.3 billion. Our EBT posted 25% growth year-over-year, delivering BRL3.7 billion. Our net income reached BRL3.3 billion, expanding 17% year-over-year, and it was the highest in our history in the quarter at almost BRL1.2 billion with 27.5% margin. This set of results indicate that we are at the right pace to meet the 2026 guidance released in the last year's Investor Day. We will go into more details on the financials later on. Going to balance sheet and profitability. We ended the quarter with an ROTE of 28.4%, an increase of 258 bps year-over-year. Our managerial BIS ratio was 21.5%, and the EPS was BRL2.18 per share, the all-time high in our history. On the right, you can see that EPS since the IPO grew almost 4 times, reaching BRL7.93 in the last 12 months. Today, we also announced an extra payout of BRL3 billion, contemplating dividends and a new share buyback program. Recently, we commented that we are targeting to deliver more than 50% payout until 2026. This year, it's well above it. All in all, we keep our targets to 2026 to reach a BIS ratio between 16% and 19% with more than 50% payout in the next couple of years. Our capital discipline in how we operate our business considers an efficient capital allocation…

Victor Mansur

Management

Thanks, Maffra. Good evening, everyone. It's a pleasure to be here with you. And before we go to the results of the quarter, I would like to recall some ideas anticipating the second quarter of 2024. First, in the second quarter, we explained that warehousing assets by underwriting more fixed-income offerings would drive an increase in our wholesale revenues, particularly is in the issue services. At the same time, we anticipated a lagging impact on retail until the distribution phase of those offerings. As expected, when the distribution phase of those offerings took place this quarter, we observed a positive impact on retail fixed-income revenues. Second, for the reason just mentioned, in the second quarter, we have increased our balance sheet, growing BRL10 billion in corporate securities in a single quarter as part of our warehousing business. And finally, we had also anticipated that revenue mix along with a few other minor effects result in a higher EBT margin and tax rate in the second quarter. We emphasized that using a trailing 12-month metric for both would serve as a more reliable guide for expectation in the coming quarters. With that in mind, remember that the last quarter, we focused on discussing our last 12 months' figures. We are evolving the right way to deliver our commitments in 2026, and the third quarter of 2024 was a positive quarter with the retail business on the spotlight. Total gross revenue grew 17% on nine months of 2024, and 4% year-over-year. Retail was the highlight during the quarter. Corporate and issue services posted solid results and institutional revenue was flattish quarter-over-quarter. On the high-hand side of this slide, we see our gross revenue breakdown and retail increased participation to 77% on total revenues on the back of another positive quarter for fixed-income.…

Thiago Maffra

Management

Thanks, Victor. So before we go to the Q&A, I would like to emphasize four things. First, we had another solid quarter confirming that we are on track to deliver our 2026 guidance. Second, as we presented, our levers are delivering positive results with BRL25 billion net-new money this quarter, and indicating that our target should deliver around BRL20 billion per quarter is feasible. Third, we believe we are enhancing our moats by offering to our clients the most complete and sophisticated product platform in the country, expanding our best-trained sales force, and evolving our value proposition properly to each segment through better offering, objectives and higher level of service excellence. And lastly, our commitment to manage our Company with capital discipline, efficiency, and return to our shareholders. Once executed, we will have returned more than BRL10.5 billion to shareholders throughout the last three years. Now, Andre Parize will start the Q&A session.

A - Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Now we're going to start our Q&A. Attending you on the first come first serve basis. First question is from Thiago Batista, UBS. Thiago, you may proceed.

Thiago Batista

Management

Hello, guys. Can you hear me?

Andre Parize

Management

Yes.

Thiago Batista

Management

Okay. Thanks, Parize, Maffra, and Victor. I have two questions. The first one called the attention, the increase [technical difficulty] about 400 new individuals is relevant the amount of those guys that went to the B2C advisor or not? And my second question. I know that you don't have a guidance for profitability or [haut or haute] but can you give to us a ballpark idea of what level of profitability that you believe XP will have in the long term? And by the way, you are looking more to haut or haute?

Thiago Maffra

Management

Hi, Thiago. Thank you for your question. Good evening to all. It's a pleasure to be here. I will take the first question and Victor will answer the second one. Out of the about 400 employees, 300 adds to B2C, they are advisors. Why you don't see that increase on the total number of advisers because we had a change in regulation a few months back, and now the IFAs, they don't need the IFAs partners, imagine the managers, the people that work not as advisors on the IFAs. They don't need any more to be IFAs. So now they are under employee contract agreements and they are like leaving the IFA number. So if you look the total number at [indiscernible] it's going down, okay, and it's not because people are leaving the profession of advisories because of this new change in regulation and they are becoming regular employees in Brazil, okay. So out of the 400 people that we hired internally, 300 went to the B2C as advisors. Okay.

Victor Mansur

Management

Perfect. Thank you. I will take the second question about ROE. Looking at our ROTE number of 28%, you can say that our return on capital employed is around that. And after we deliver our guidance of base index by the end of the guidance, you can expect ROE will be mid-to-high 20s.

Thiago Batista

Management

No, very clear, Maffra and Victor.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Next question is from Eduardo Rosman, BTG. Rosman, you may proceed.

Eduardo Rosman

Management

Hi, guys. Good evening. I want to talk more about capital allocation, and Victor, I think he talked a lot about it. He came up with new information as well. So I wanted to get more details about the RWA, what could -- can we expect in terms of growth for next year and maybe in the mid-term, if there is kind of a gains of scale there on operational risk or market risk, if you grow more eventually if there is room to improve efficiency there. Now you also have the ability to issue Tier 1 and Tier 2 so if you see room to do that and eventually bring your core Tier 1 down. At the end of the day, I'm trying to understand what level of payout in the form of dividends and buybacks, we can probably work in the next two years, right? You paid out -- you have a very high payout in the last couple of years, right, so I wanted to have an idea if we can work with something of at least 50% for the next couple of years. Thanks.

Victor Mansur

Management

Okay. Thank you for your question, Rosman. First, there is operational leverage in the RWA numbers that can give you a color. If you look at our revenues in issuer service and corporate, which is basically a more capital-intensive business, the revenues grew 38% in the last 12 months and the RWA grew only 30%. So there is a gain between the relation in revenue and the RWA. And when you go to marketing operational RWA, also our gains that we can make over the years using more efficiency structures as they -- as now, we can use the bank in his full capacity. Talking about payout, you can expect 50% or more of our net income paid in 2025 and '26, that should be the levels to reach our guidance in terms of BIS ratio, and after that, we should stabilize near 30%.

Eduardo Rosman

Management

Awesome. Thanks a lot.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Our next question is from Yuri Fernandes from JPMorgan. Yuri, you may proceed.

Yuri Fernandes

Management

Hello, Parize, thank you. Hi, Maffra and Victor. A quick one just on Rosman question. Just making sure that 21.5% still does not reflect the BR2 billion, right? It should maybe drop to 19.5% without any capital generation for the next quarter. So very quickly this. And if I may, a second one, just on the order line, Parize, what happened with the orders? It was about 40% decrease quarter-over-quarter. So if you can provide a little bit of explanation what hurt that line this quarter. Thank you.

Victor Mansur

Management

Sorry. Thank you for your question, Yuri. The BIS ratio in the end of the quarter was actually 21.5%, and after the dividend, it goes to 19%, and considering the buyback then, it goes to 18.3%. And as we said, you can expect that we will pay more than 50% of our earnings in the next two years, and after that, our payout ratio should normalize between 30% and 50% of our net income. Going to the second question about other revenue, in this quarter, we had a one-off event. In the beginning of the quarter, we tender almost half of our outstanding 2026 notes and issue a new 2029 bond. Remember that those notes that we tender, they were hedged to Brazilian CDI and buy them back, we had to undo the hedge accounting. And by undoing the hedge accounting, we discharge all the P&L in the net income. And if you consider all the transaction, the carry of the new debt is cheaper than the one that we bought in CDI plus levels. So over time, the P&L of the transaction is positive. But in this quarter, we had this one-off event that reduced the other revenue line and you should expect that we'll be back to average levels in the next quarter.

Yuri Fernandes

Management

Super clear. Thank you for the explanation on this point.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Our next question is from Mario Pierry, Bank of America. Mario, you may proceed.

Mario Pierry

Management

Hi, guys, good evening. Let me ask you three quick questions. Two of them are follow-ups. First one, Maffra, you talked about you using more internal salespeople, right? However, when I look at the commissions paid to IFAs, they are growing faster than retail revenues. So in fact, right, we calculated a ratio of 25.8% this quarter, last year was 24.6%, previous quarter 25.7%. So when do we see the benefits of lower IFA commissions as you start to use your own internal salespeople? And as you mentioned, right, you had to add about 300 people this quarter so I'm assuming we're going to see higher SG&A and that should be compensated by lower IFA commissions. So I was wondering why that did not happen. The second question is very quick. If you can just talk about the impact of the Expert events on revenues and on expenses. I think that they net out, but just to be clear, how much did you book in expenses and revenues this quarter? And then the third one really is when we were looking at the revenues from credit, we see your loan book is flat -- relatively flat year-over-year. However, your credit revenues went from BRL71 million to BRL113 million. Was there anything unusual on the credit revenues? Thank you.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Thank you, Mario. So the first question about the commission costs. It's really hard to see a change in COGS quarter like a the B2C channel making a change in COGS from a quarter to the next one. You have to see this trend in a longer period of time, like in a year or two, because if we have a very small change in revenue mix, it can change everything, okay? So remember what we said in Q2, we did a lot of revenues on investment banking, on credit issuance. And on 3Q, we distribute a lot of this credit portfolio. And when we distribute, we make revenue on the retail and we pay commissions, okay? So it's a completely different COGS when you compare what you do on -- when you book the primary market from the investment banking to when you distribute like to -- on the secondary market, okay, one you pay commission, the other one you don't pay. So it's basically a revenue mix. That's why you're not seeing a big change. But if you have to look like a longer trend to see this effects, okay? About the second one, we don't open how much we spend on Expert, but it's net zero, okay? So for a few years, it was slightly negative last year. This year was zero, okay. So it's not even positive, but it's very important for us because it's one of the largest financial -- if not the largest one in the world about investments. So it's really important for the brand, but it's net zero and some years is slightly negative. Victor will take the last one.

Victor Mansur

Management

Okay. Thank you for the question. About the credit, we had two explanations. The first is the beginning of margin loan operations in the broker-dealer, which are more profitable than conventional credit, and the second one, some loans from the COVID area is lower NII mature during this quarter and they were renovated by new operations if this new normal of price if higher NII. Basically, that is the explanation. The book is almost flat, but to have two new products with higher NII than before.

Mario Pierry

Management

Okay, that's clear. Maffra, let me just like a follow up here then on the gross profit and gross margin, right? Because you provide guidance for EBT margin, I think 30% to 34%, you're running at 28% right now. The improvement in margin, does it come from the gross margin, or where should we see the improvement coming from?

Thiago Maffra

Management

Okay. Thank you for your question. Talking about the guidance, we can give you some color about the improvement. First is operational leverage. You can see our efficiency ratio in the lowest level ever and we expect that this ratio will keep improving over the next year. This is one factor. Another factor is the J-curve of the cross-sell verticals that we have. We mentioned before that credit cards, for example, they had losses in 2022. They also lose money in '23. This is the first year that they will make positive margins and that grow over our guidance period. Other verticals as they -- our own internal sales force also lost money over 2022 and '23. This is the first year of positive margin. And as they grow, they start being accretive in terms of EBT. And basically, those three things together can explain the expansion in margins.

Mario Pierry

Management

Great. Thank you very much.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Our next question is from Tito Labarta from Goldman Sachs. Tito, you may proceed.

Tito Labarta

Management

Hi. Good evening, guys. Thank you for the call and taking my question. Just a couple of questions on the revenues. Continued good performance on the fixed-income retail revenues. How do you think that line sort of continues to evolve? I mean, do you think you're benefiting from a higher-rate environment? Is there room for that line to continue to grow into next year? Just to understand a little bit the growth dynamic there. And then on the issuer services revenue line, right? I mean it's been a good year overall, tough comps in 2Q, so down a bit this quarter. Do you think that comes back in 4Q and into next year? Just help us think about sort of DCM activity and how you feel about the issuer services revenues. Thank you.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Hi, Tito. Thank you for your question. And a second, please. Answer both of them together. DCM industry in Brazil is a new level. Our pipeline remained robust and most likely this same activity remains strong in the next quarters. As well, the demand for fixed-income coming from our distribution channels, both retail and institutional is very strong. So we believe that we will see both lines, DCM and fixed-income lines strong over the next quarter and next year. And also, you need to take into consideration the impact of our corporate restructuring. If the bank in a more competitive level, we can originate more deals in the same. We can warehouse more fixed-income and that increases our compactivity in both of those lines. So we are optimist for both in the next year and next quarter.

Tito Labarta

Management

Okay, perfect. That's clear. One quick clarification. Just on the BIS ratio, is that a fully loaded or Tier 1 ratio just to make sure there's anything else in the BIS ratio?

Thiago Maffra

Management

Yes, yes. That is it. It's fully loaded.

Tito Labarta

Management

Okay, perfect. Great. Thanks so much. Thank you.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Next question is from Neha Agarwala from HSBC. Neha, you may proceed.

Neha Agarwala

Management

Thank you for taking my questions. Just a quick one on the credit growth. Credit book was flat year-on-year. What should we expect going forward? Why don't we see a more strong growth on the credit side? Thank you so much.

Victor Mansur

Management

Hi, Neha. So one important thing when we think about credit for XP, one main point for us, we don't want to pile up credit. So you cannot expect us like coming back here one year ahead and saying that now we have like BRL100 billion -- BRL200 billion in corporate credit. So we don't have this strategy. We don't have the business to pile up credit. Of course, as the wholesale bank grows, we have to warehouse a higher amount of volumes from investment banking, for corporate bond flows, and for other business lines, for example, credit risk from the derivatives. So as the business grows, it will grow in nominal terms, for sure, but not on the same growth rate as the business grows, okay. So the idea here is always to recycle capital, okay, and recycle fast. It's always to give credit with some collateral and that's the strategy. So we don't have any strategy to pile up a big credit portfolio here, okay.

Neha Agarwala

Management

Very clear. Thank you so much.

Andre Parize

Management

Next question is from Daniel Vaz, Safra. Daniel, you may proceed.

Daniel Vaz

Management

Thank you, Parize. Hi, Maffra and Victor. Good goodnight. So two here on my side. Looking at your expenses, I was trying to see beyond XP Expert, so we see the other revenue -- other income and other expenses net line. So we have another quarter of incentives coming from [indiscernible] and also a positive recoveries in reversal provisions. Can you comment on that please so we can get a sense on what are these other operating income were way higher than a year ago? And second, trying to see and get more color on your equity income, or is your name in the release or share of profit on JVs and associate. So it went from BRL41 million to negative BRL3 million quarter-over-quarter. So any seasonality effects here, maybe associates pay higher-cost to have a stand in XP Expert. So if you can get a color here, it will be very helpful. Thank you.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Thank you for the question, Daniel. I will split the answer in three parts here. You first asked about the incentives, okay. So as we have built one of the largest distribution channels in Brazil, we have today more than 18,000 advisors. Every time that we launch a new product, we have some players in the industry that want to have access to our distribution. And what happened, usually they pay some fees. It can be upfront and it can be based on performance. It depends on the product and on the partner, okay? But it's recurring, okay. There is not an amount that's recurring every month, but it's recurring to have this kind of one-offs, okay, from different partners from credit cards, from B3, from consortium, from other players, okay, from whole-life insurance. So you guys can expect this type of one-offs to be recurring, okay, so because it's part of giving access to these partners to our distribution. The second question that you asked it was about the reversion in provisions. I imagine that it's the -- on the expected credit loss that you mentioned. We had a BRL42 million from the Aqua payment, there was a provision and it was reverted. So a good way of thinking about expected credit loss for a regular quarter, it's BRL80 million, okay. That's a good number, okay, -- around this number. It can be a little bit less, a little bit more because we have some credit on the wholesale book that is less stable, but that's a good proxy, okay? And the third one about [indiscernible] interest that you ask, it was BRL41 million last quarter. It was almost zero this quarter. We have done some deals with different players, with some asset management, with especially IFAs. And some of them, they are like going through some reorganizations, as I mentioned, some of them, they are like going to employee agreements, some of them, they are like in different states. But I would say that for next year, you can expect this line to be a little bit higher than this year, okay, and a little bit more stable than this year, okay, because we have a lot of reorganizations this year and these investments that we have done in the past years in IFAs, assets and other business, they will start to pay-off next year, okay? So it's going to be a little bit higher.

Daniel Vaz

Management

Okay. Thank you for the detailed answer. Very helpful.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Next question is from Henrique Navarro from Santander. Henrique, you may proceed. Navarro, are you listening to us? We're going to move to the next one. If Navarro comes up we're going to tell you. So the next one is Andrew Geraghty from Morgan Stanley. Andrew, you may proceed.

Andrew Geraghty

Management

Hi, everyone. Congratulations on the results and thank you for the opportunity to ask questions. I just wanted to briefly touch on the take rate, which was certainly a highlight of the quarter, expanding on a sequential basis. It looks like a lot of the improvement kind of came from the fixed-income retail take rate and so just kind of wanted to ask, I know you had mentioned some new products on the fixed-income side. Is there anything in particular that makes you believe that this like higher take rate on fixed-income specifically is sustainable? Or is this again just kind of a quarter-to-quarter fluctuation? Thanks.

Victor Mansur

Management

Hi, Andrew. Thank you for your question. Basically, the highlight of the quarter in the retail line was fixed income, and that was drive the take rate higher. And as we expect the retail revenue to keep growing in the pace of our guidance, you can expect the take rate to be stable, or slightly higher than what it is today.

Andrew Geraghty

Management

Okay. Thank you.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Just to complement Victor here. We have been mentioning that for a few quarters, I would say, when we think about take rate, when you look at our guidance, we didn't factor a better take rate into the guidance. But if you ask our view, at some point the market will change and we expect to see a change in the mix of products toward more higher ROA products, okay, because most of the money flew to fixed-income products with low ROA in the past quarters or years. At some point that we will revert and we can expect a higher take rate. So that's our view. But a higher take rate is not factored into our guidance for 2026. So you can consider that an upside if it starts to go up.

Andrew Geraghty

Management

Okay, got it. But you do think that at least over the coming quarters, take rate, as mentioned earlier, should be somewhat flat to slightly higher from here is a reasonable assumption.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Yes.

Andrew Geraghty

Management

Okay. Thank you.

Thiago Maffra

Management

Parize, can you hear me now?

Andre Parize

Management

[Breno Pavone] from Autonomous. Breno, you may proceed.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

Hi. Hello. Can you guys hear me?

Andre Parize

Management

Yes.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

Hi. This is Renato Meloni from Autonomous. I think it was just a link issue here. So I just wanted to deep-dive on the fixed-income take rate that saw a large expansion this quarter, right? So can you explain the breakdown here of how much was client activity and how much was from the securities that you're having or mark-to-market of securities you're having in your balance sheet? And then further down, just thinking here of the dynamics that we're seeing in market with spreads compressing and the cycle rates, how do you expect the fixed-income take rate to behave in the next couple of quarters? Thank you.

Victor Mansur

Management

Hi. Thank you, Andrew. We don't close this level -- sorry, thank you, Renato. We don't close this level of detail in the fixed-income line. What we can say is that almost everything that we are housing the last quarter, we sold this one and that was one of the drivers of the revenue.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

Okay. Thanks. And then just --

Victor Mansur

Management

About the credit spreads, we are seeing some inflection, but as we said before, the DCM pipeline is still very hot and the demand for -- the client demand is still all-time high. So we don't expect any structural changes in the market.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

Okay. So similar take rates in the next few quarters.

Victor Mansur

Management

It is better and bigger than ever before.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

I guess, sorry. I don't know if you could hear me. So similar take rates -- fixed-income take rates in the next quarter?

Victor Mansur

Management

Yes, we believe so.

Unidentified Analyst

Management

Okay. Thank you.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. Next question is Henrique.

Henrique Navarro

Management

Hi, Parize. Can you hear me now? Hello?

Andre Parize

Management

Navarro, are you there?

Henrique Navarro

Management

Yes. Can you hear me now?

Andre Parize

Management

Yes, we can. You may proceed, please.

Henrique Navarro

Management

Sorry for that. My question is on competition. All the large banks have been advancing if they are all IFAs, I for internal, financial advisors as well as improving the open investment platforms. The level of competition XP is facing was not there like maybe two, three years ago and it has been increasing. How do you see this advancement of competition from the large banks affecting your businesses?

Thiago Maffra

Management

Thanks for the question, Navarro. I would say of course the incumbent banks, they are not sitting down, doing nothing, okay, but for us the most structural change in the last, I would say, two years, it's not that the banks -- the incumbent banks, they improved a lot in investments, and the main reason is the high-interest rates, tax-exempt products and so on, okay. So if you look some of these incumbent banks without giving any names, they didn't improve at all, okay, in investments. But when you look the NPS from affluent clients from the same bank, the NPS went up like 40 bps. The main reason is the level of profitability that they can have with just tax-exempt products. So it's a little bit harder to compete with the incumbent banks with this environment, but again, we are not like blaming the macro-environment. We are not waiting the macro to get better, and our guidance doesn't depend on the macro environment. That's an upside. But for us, it's more the environment and the structural change in most of these incumbent banks.

Henrique Navarro

Management

Thank you very much. That was very clear.

Andre Parize

Management

Okay. This is -- that was the last question. So we thank you for your participation. And our team and the management are available for further questions. It will be a pleasure to answer anyone that you send to us. Thank you and we talk soon.