Joseph Moreno
Analyst · CJS Securities
Thank you, John. Good morning, everyone. Let me add my welcome to all of you. Thank you for joining us. As this has become our custom, I’ll start with a few introductory comments to give all of you a feel for how we think about this quarter and also for how we think about our outlook and then we’ll go to your questions.
If you set aside the effects of the sale of the Doors business, Q4 2011 is on the surface, a pretty simple quarter. That seasonal weakness in PMC that we have been expecting was offset by good performance in AEC and PrimaLoft. The overall result is flat, year-over-year performance. So, if you exclude the discontinued operation, currency effects, restructuring and the gain on that building we sold last year, EBITDA in Q4 ‘11 is essentially the same as EBITDA in Q4 ‘10, $32.3 million this year excluding Doors and $32.6 million last year excluding Doors.
Now, to properly assess this quarter and what it tells you about our outlook, we think it is important to focus on 5 factors in particular. First, there is the accounting treatment of the Doors transaction. Many of you will recall that the Doors business was centered in Germany, it still is, and a good fraction of the profits are generated there. Without the Doors business, our ability to generate future profit in Germany will be significantly reduced, that is why we recorded in Q4 a large reserve against the deferred tax assets in Germany and that is what creates the loss in overall company net income in Q4.
Now, since the sale did not actually close until January, it is a gain from the sale which will be considerably larger than that reserve, will not be recorded until Q1, so we will see the opposite effect next quarter. Q1 net income will be inflated by the gain from the sale.
That brings us to issue #2 and in our minds the real story in Q4, which is the seasonality in PMC. If you go back a year Q4 2010 and Q1 2011, the paper industry was at a very different stage in the business cycle than it is today. Up and down the supply chain, the industry was restocking. Our backlogs and delivery times were abnormally high and we were running our plants at high rates right through the quarter. But this year, by Q4 2011 the industry was well past the restocking phase of the business cycle and if anything, parts of the industry were destocking towards the end of the year. We responded accordingly with production slowdowns in December culminating in plant shutdowns at the end of the month.
The effect of the slowdown was most pronounced on our gross margins. If you look at October and November, our margins were among the strongest of the year. In December, they were sharply lower and well below the PMC average. We will see a similar set of comparisons in Q1 2012. The slowdown at the end of Q4 means a slow start at the beginning of Q1, whereas the year earlier, the strong finish to the year flowed into an unusually strong January. So, it is unlikely that PMC performance in Q1 2012 will compare favorably to PMC performance in Q1 2011.On the other hand, orders did strengthen this January. We are expecting performance to strengthen as the quarter and year progresses and we continue to expect full year PMC performance in 2012, to be in line with full year PMC performance in 2011.
The third important factor this quarter was AEC which along with PrimaLoft performed well. AEC grew 20% year-over-year in Q4 and was EBITDA positive. For 2012, we expect AEC to grow more than 20%, while EBITDA will remain roughly constant with 2011, at little above breakeven, because of those heavy 1x expenses associated with intense hiring, but growth, we will see probably more than 20%.
As discussed in the release, we view 2012 as pivotal to the ramp of the LEAP program and we are working closely and effectively with our customer SAFRAN group to execute on that ramp.
Fourth, we have now completed the integration of engineered fabrics and paper machine clothing and beginning with Q1 2012 we will present combined results to this now unified business and we continue to expect by mid-2013 about $15 million in incremental EBITDA from the synergies created by this business.
Returning to the fifth factor of significance in this release. Now that the sale of Doors has closed, we are finalizing our plan to use the proceeds to aggressively strengthen our balance sheet. In John’s commentary in the release, he lays out significant and considerable detail, how we plan to invest the proceeds to significantly reduce our pension liabilities as well as our long-term debt.
Our goal is to have this plan completely implemented by the end of Q2 which means that we should see the full impact on income, cash flow, and the balance sheet beginning in Q3. Now, these 5 factors together the accounting treatment of the Doors transaction, seasonality in PMC, strong performance in AEC and PrimaLoft, the integration of PMC and EF and the plan for investing the proceeds of the sale by mid-year. All of those together lead us to the following outlook: For 2012, excluding the Q1 gain from the sale of Doors and the Q2 charge associated with the pension liability reduction plan. We expect modest improvement in year-over-year performance. EBIDTA from PMC and AEC are likely to be flat in 2012 compared to 2011, so the improvement will come primarily from the impact of our plan to reduce pension liability along with continued growth in PrimaLoft.
For 2013, we expect stronger year-over-year improvement in performance driven primarily by the synergies from the merger of PMC and EF, coupled with a full year of reduced pension expenses. And for 2014 and beyond, we expect continued improvements in year-over-year performance, to be driven by AEC as growth in its EBITDA begins to contribute to overall company performance. And for the entire period, 2012, 2013, and 2014 and beyond, we expect continued strong generation of excess cash particularly with the substantially lower requirements for contribution to our pension plans.
So that’s how we look at this quarter, 5 factors together laying out the outlook and what we will do now is just turn to your questions. Thank you, operator.