Robert Whitman
Analyst · Barrington Research
Thanks, Derek. I'm happy to have a chance to talk with all of you today. I've enjoyed talking to a number of you over the last few days. And inasmuch as you all have had the press release and we've talked, today, I'd just like to maybe hit some headlines. I know we're competing with the World Cup game, and we'll understand if we hear cheering in the background. But we appreciate you joining us.
I'd just like to briefly address 4 topics. Let me just hit on the results for the third quarter, give a little more detail on the shift of the -- the economic shift of the $2.4 million of revenue from Q3 to Q4, then give an update on our progress on the overall business plan and thesis of growing double digit and flowing through 30%, and then give our -- just review our outlook for Q4 and beyond.
So I'll start with our third quarter results, which you've seen the detail of. I'll just hit some headlines. Third quarter for us was generally a very solid quarter in terms of revenue growth. As you can see on Slide 3, we achieved growth in all of our major channels, except for government services. Our direct geographic offices in the U.S. and Canada posted 7% growth for the quarter on top of 19% growth in the second quarter and had 12% growth for the trailing 4 quarters. But for the shift of revenue to the third quarter, most of which occurred in these offices, their growth would have been, of course, stronger. And we expect to be very strong in the fourth quarter, independent of the shift and in adding that shift to it to be even stronger.
Second, our international direct offices achieved growth of 12% for the quarter. This has been an area of focus for us over the past years. And we were pleased that despite some foreign exchange challenges, these offices were still able to post significant growth. And this is something we're excited about. They are implementing the same marketing and go-to-market hiring plans, and we're starting to see that move the needle on the growth rate in international direct offices.
Our international licensee operations grew 11%, reflecting ongoing efforts to employ the same hiring and marketing initiatives that are driving revenue in our direct offices. 7 Habits launched, which has gotten off to a strong start in our direct offices in the U.S. and U.K. and Australia, is just now starting in most of our international partner offices. So we look forward to accelerated growth in the fourth quarter and particularly in the first and second quarters of next year.
Our National Account Practices grew 20% for the quarter, reflecting growth in each of our Education, Customer Loyalty and Sales Performance practices. And so the growth in all these areas, the main channels, were partially offset -- was partially offset by a $1.7 million decline in the Government Services area that was expected. The renewal of the large government contract, which had occurred in last year's third quarter, has been deferred until the fourth quarter of this year. Approximately $1 million of adjusted EBITDA contribution came from that renewal in last year's third quarter, which should not repeat in this year's third quarter.
So overall, we felt very good about the growth. We'd like to see greater growth in the direct offices in the U.S., which we'll address, but which they've had in the past and which we are confident they'll have in the future.
In terms of our practices, as shown on Slide 4, the Leadership, Education and Customer Loyalty practices achieved significant growth during the quarter: 35% for Leadership, 30% for Education, 39% for Customer Loyalty. Growth in the Leadership practice was driven by the launch of the re-created 7 Habits Signature 4.0 offering. And the extent of the focus on the launch of 7 Habits in the second and third quarter to establish this launch firmly among both our existing clients and new clients impacted the Productivity, Speed of Trust and Execution practices revenue during the second and third quarters as we essentially shut off those events just to allow full focus on getting 7 Habits established.
Speed of Trust was down more than others during the quarter because in last year's third quarter, we had a big Speed of Trust tour, which generated exceptional revenues in that quarter. But we expect these practices to resume growth during the fourth quarter as we once again have ongoing marketing events in each of these practice areas. And we expect that by the first quarter, all of the practices will be back in full growth mode again.
So that's kind of the summary of the results. Obviously, there will be plenty of time for questions and answers.
The second topic I'd like to address, is just the shift of revenue from third quarter into the fourth quarter that we discussed in the press release.
Despite the broad-based growth of the company overall, the company's revenue growth was somewhat less than we'd expected for the third quarter. As we've analyzed and re-analyzed almost all of that, more than 100% of it was due to approximately $2.4 million of revenue that we had expected to be recognized in the third quarter, which shifted and either has already been realized in the fourth quarter or is expected to be realized during the fourth quarter. This shift of revenue into the fourth quarter accounts for, as I mentioned, more than 100% of the variance in gross profit, adjusted EBITDA, operating income and net income compared to that which we'd expected for the quarter. Thankfully approximately $1 million of this revenue has already been recognized in June.
The revenue shift fell into 2 basic categories: First, last minute delay in the signing of 2 specific contracts, which totaled approximately $600,000 in revenue, and because of their high intellectual property content, would have had an effect of about $0.5 million of adjusted EBITDA. The larger of those was signed in June, and the other contract is out for final signature now.
The second component of that was the encouraging, but earlier-than-expected shift in the mix of new client prospects as compared to the company's existing client facilitators attending 7 Habits launch events during the third quarter compared to the second quarter. As we've noted, new clients typically have a somewhat longer average conversion period than do the company's existing client facilitators. And we believe that this increased mix of new clients and the decreased mix of existing client facilitators have resulted in the shift of approximately $1.8 million of 7 Habits revenue into the fourth quarter, which resulted in a commensurate increase in the company's prospective business pipeline for 7 Habits at the end of the third quarter.
Let me just provide a little more detail on this shift of 7 Habits revenue. First, it might be worthwhile noting that overall, the revenue generated from the launch of the new 7 Habits offering has substantially exceeded expectations for second and third quarters.
In our January conference call, we said that our expectation for the new offering was to generate $3 million to $4 million of new 7 Habits revenue in the second quarter, $4 million to $5 million in the third quarter and $5 million to $6 million in the fourth quarter. As noted in the press release, the actual new 7 Habits revenue for the first 2 quarters was approximately $11.2 million, exceeding the upper range of our expectations for those 2 quarters by more than $2 million.
So the issue in the second quarter wasn't one of the -- of the launch not being as successful as we'd thought it would be overall; but was that based on the revenue, the $5.7 million of revenue generated in the second quarter, where we had thought we'd generate $3 million to $4 million, and the amount that have been generated from these launch events during the second quarter, we projected a similar result into the third quarter, but the mix of participants shifted somewhat. Let me walk through a few slides that may provide some additional insight.
Slide 5 shows that approximately the same -- in the first column, shows that approximately the same number of people registered for events in the second and third quarters. Because there were fewer events, a few less events in the third quarter, the actual number of registrants per event was essentially equal.
Next, in the second column over, in both quarters, these events in both quarters generated approximately the same amount of revenue plus pipeline. We look at every event we have and have had for years, we look at how much revenue is generated in the quarter and how much pipeline, and we then have the metrics on what the pipeline conversion is. It's interesting that both in the second and third quarter, we generated about the same amount of revenue plus pipeline.
So as you see in the third column, the actual revenue recognized in the third quarter was $4.1 million versus $5.7 million in the second quarter, which was $1.6 million less. But column 4 shows that, conversely, the pipeline that was generated in the third quarter was about $1.7 million or $1.8 million higher than it was in the third (sic) [second] quarter. And so the question is really what caused the shift since the overall activity and effectiveness of the events seemed to be quite similar.
Slide 6 shows what we believe it is the primary reason, which is the shift of new customers versus existing customers. And as you see there, approximately -- in the third quarter, approximately 31% of our registrants were existing customers versus 69% new. And that shifted to where -- sorry, let me flip over. In Q2 -- I've got -- we'll reverse it -- new customers were 54%; existing, 46%; and that shifted to 69% new customers and 31% existing.
And importantly, as part of that, there's a group of existing customers that's particularly important, which is those who were existing 7 Habits -- active 7 Habits facilitators as opposed to customers in other content. And that represented a much bigger share of the second quarter than it did in the third. 54% of those converted, and so the biggest impact was really the difference in the number of active 7 Habits facilitators attending in the third quarter compared to the second.
Question, is there something -- is there something wrong with that? We think the answer is no, clearly no. As I noted, the overall revenue has come in much higher. Actually, 75% of all our active 7 Habits facilitators attended either in the second or third quarter, with a little over half in the second quarter, and the other 23% or 24% in the third. In both quarters, more than half of them converted, but that was the main thing. And so I think it was our -- in retrospect, knowing the strength -- or seeing the strength of conversion and the high percentage of the existing 7 Habits facilitators who had attended an event in the second quarter, the extrapolation of the results from that quarter into the third quarter was probably in error, although we didn't know that until all the dust settled and we were close to the end of the third quarter.
So all in all, we think that's the difference. The pipeline, much of it is already converted. There's a very strong pipeline. We think that the combination of the strong pipeline that we have, together with fourth quarter incentives as we sunset the former 7.0 -- or the 3.0 7 Habits product will help the rest of them to convert. So we have a little over half of the -- a little over 40% of the active 7 Habits facilitators have already converted. We've gone through and done an analysis account by account. We think that's about half of what will convert and they'll be about 20% where because they have inventory of 3.0 or they've made big investments in translation of something in 3.0 or somebody is no longer in that position to teach in the immediate term, that about 20% won't convert now. So we expect that we'll convert about half of what we'll convert from our existing base.
Excitingly for us, on the other hand, is the tremendous response we've had from new potential companies. And so the fact that we had fewer existing customers affected the quarter, but the extent of demand and the fact that these new customers are coming in, filling the events and purchasing in a relatively short period of time, although it was longer than the existing customers, is very encouraging. There are more than 10 million managers in the United States; only about 1,500 of them have we seen in the first -- in the second and third quarters. So we think this provides a very long runway for this offering as well as for Trust and otherwise.
Let me just shift now to the third point, progress on our overall business plan and thesis. As you know, our basic business plan and thesis has been that our -- our goal has been to achieve growth at least 10% a year, with approximately 30% of incremental revenue flowing through the increases in adjusted EBITDA. I thought it might be useful, in response to also some questions I've received, just to give you an update on the overall progress. Slides 7 through 16 just provide a quick walk-through. I'll just take a few seconds per slide.
Slide 7 shows that against this goal of achieving 10% annual growth in revenue, in fact, since 2009, the compounded average growth rate has been 11.6%. You can see that it's been lumpy in some years, where the government contract may have increased in 2011, increased that growth rate some and then the decline in that contract in '12 reduced it some. But overall, we've been able to meet the growth rate. But what we want to be able to do is meet that so it's not lumpy either. And so -- but that's been the base, the first point.
As you can see in Slide 8, even though not every quarter is the same, on a rolling 4-quarter basis, each first quarter, each second quarter, each third and fourth has continued to have growth on the trailing 4-quarter basis. And we expect that to continue into the future.
Slide 9 shows that our revenue per channel over the period of years has also grown well. Self-funded marketing and other, those are ones that won't change much. The other is the rent on our sale-leaseback facility. Self-funded marketing is just that. I mean, it's speeches and public programs and things that we've reduced our focus on. But our National Account Practices have grown extremely well. Our international licensee business has grown dramatically on a gross revenue. Our royalties grow at the same pace but off a smaller base. Our international direct offices have grown, and that's despite significant pressure on -- FX pressure over the last 2 years.
Government Services has actually grown overall, but it's been up and down. And then our direct offices in the U.S. and Canada, without government, have grown substantially and have been a major growth engine. The things we've learned and done there are now being translated both in the international direct and our international licensee offices and National Account Practices.
Slide 10 shows that practice-by-practice, our revenue growth has also been substantial. And we have these goals for these practices. And thankfully, we have -- basically, all those goals have been met to date, and we feel good about each practice. It does not mean we don't have challenges or things we think about every day and ways we can accelerate growth, but we feel fundamentally we've made good progress in each.
Slide 11 shows that what has been driving this growth is kind of 2 things. One that you don't see on the slide, which is our focus on quality results for clients. It's our #1 objective as a company. And during the period of years, our recurring revenue, the repeat revenue from 1 year -- revenue from 1 year -- the clients that repeat in the next has gone from the high 60s to the low 90s. And that's been really important. It's also ultimately the thing that we're about as a company, it's the thing that will drive our -- it drives our mission and our revenue and profitability.
The other thing that's driven it, though, is the increase in the size and productivity of our sales force. You can see in Slide 11, the sales force has increased from 101 to 169 at the end of the third quarter. And by the time of our sales kickoff training conference in end of September, we expect to be at that 180 goal. That means that really that by the time we reported last year -- we reported on the year in November, we had about 145 Client Partners. We've hired 24 since then. But really, since this actual year end, where we had 130 at the actual August 31, we've added 36 new Client Partners. So it's been a big hiring year. And what's been very exciting about it is with the addition of our sales management position with all of our marketing events, et cetera, we've both hit our -- Client Partners are both hitting or exceeding ramp, and we've also lost very, very few. And so the retention rate has also gone up, so this has been a key thing.
Slide 12 says that also to be able to build that to capacity, to be hiring 30-plus Client Partners a year has taken some real investment. Slide 12 shows the investments in just the field support practice, the practice support and central sales and licensee support. And so that's gone from $11 million a year in 2011 to $18 million in 2013. We've said in previous calls that we expect to be able to hold the line or maybe even reduce this slightly. And you can see that for 2014, these investments have flattened out. We might have a small decrease next year. But the point is that certainly, adding to these investments, on one hand, has made it more difficult to -- has tightened the spread and the flow-through in quarters, but now reaching the point, where we in fact, are hiring and ramping up more salespeople, that also now on the flattened investments will allow us -- investment plan will allow us to flow through a lot more.
The next slide shows also that in order to support the -- Slide 13 shows that in order to support the hiring and ramping up of salespeople and to increase the number of face-to-face hours we're spending with the client, in 2013, the left bars, we added 22 new Client Partners but we added 2 support people -- 45 support people for the 22. And for one 12-month period, it was as high as 3:1. This year, it's closer to 1:1. You see 32 net hires, and 37 support positions. We expect that will go to a little less than 1:1 in 2015 and beyond. And so again, this flow-through will help us.
The other thing that helps a lot is the fact that when you step up, when you increase the number of new hires from 20 to 30, there's an enormous increase in investment. I mean, the 30 people have a net investment of $3 million in their -- have a $3 million payroll their first year plus marketing and other things. It is largely offset but not completely offset, but it does compress the margins.
In the second year of those people's tenure, however, they each had about $300,000 of revenue, with no increase in costs. And so you have an extra $9 million of revenue generating almost 70% gross margin. And since we expected them flatlining for the next few years about 30 net new hires a year, that incremental increase, again, should reduce. And so the flow-through, if you go to Slide 14 -- I'm sorry. One page before this.
Let's go to Slide 14. The payoff for doing this if we can succeed is shown on page -- or Slide 14, where if we can hire 30 net new Client Partners a year, by the fifth year, you've got an extra $117 million of revenue. Flowing through, we expect at about 30% and yet only 1 of the 5 classes is ramped up, dividing [ph] the fifth year. The others are still in ramp, suggesting that there's initial additional growth available embedded in that sales force. As there is right now, in our 169, there are almost 100 of them, they're still in some form of ramp up. And so we expect now significant flow-through of incremental revenue from the existing people who are ramping up, from the new people who are ramping up, but with flat-to-down central support costs and much reduced incremental field support costs.
Page 15, Slide 15 shows the flow-through. We've had revenue growth on the top of about -- on average, it's been 11.6% over the last 4 years compounded. In 2013, it was 12%. You can see that also the flow-through goal of about 30%, actually we've exceeded that over the last 4 years, but not in the last couple. So we've had 41% -- 42% flow-through of incremental revenue to incremental EBITDA. Our goal has been 30%. But in '13, when we're making all these incremental investments as well as the investments in the launch of 7 Habits, that dropped to 21.2%. We expect to move forward in the fourth quarter to have a flow-through of well north of 30% in the fourth quarter.
And moving into the next year, it will -- we will quite confidently count on 30% initial flow-through. I might note that the flow-through, of course, in '13 and '12, to some extent, but '13, was impacted meaningfully by the devaluation of the yen and by the deduction in the size of the government contract that costs us almost $4 million of EBITDA. And so our goal is knowing that the core business is strong and then growing well, we have had some of these issues that make some quarters lumpy. We expect with the hiring of the salespeople, we'll get to the point where our core business can offset any potholes that we have in foreign currency or the government thing and that we can be growing top line 10% plus organically and flowing through.
Slide 16 kind of shows how that's gone. So I hope that review is useful. We'll certainly look forward to answering your questions.
Finally, in terms of the outlook, maybe just for the outlook, I'll just summarize on the strategic initiatives that the size of the company's direct sales forces continue to expand. You've seen that. Productivity continues to meet or exceed our expectations. Our licensee partner network continues to expand. The number of international licensee partners has now increased to 52, including our Education licensee partners, and that will expand further. The company's repeating revenue continues to be high, with our focus on quality results as our #1 objective. More than 90% of the revenue generated by clients in the trailing 4-quarter period ended a year ago, repeated in this year's fourth quarter -- last -- latest 4 quarters. And that the launch of the re-created 7 Habits signature product is ahead of pace.
Finally, in terms of outlook, the booking momentum continues to be strong. You saw the press release. Our corporate pipeline of booked days and awarded revenue increased by 7% to more than $36 million, which represents our largest ever corporate pipeline for the end of the third quarter. Interestingly, as predictive as the corporate pipeline typically is of future revenue growth, it turns out that at the end of the third quarter, it's not as predictive of the fourth because such a high percentage of our revenue in the fourth quarter comes from facilitator sales, and which means that the pipeline as a percentage of the total pipeline only include booked days and contractual revenue. And so we feel pretty good about the momentum of the facilitator business and expect that will -- our growth will exceed 7% in the fourth quarter.
The corporate and education booked day momentum was strong, increasing 13% during the quarter. The overall perspective business pipelines, which do include the facilitator sales, reached the highest levels ever for the end of the third quarter. And so we feel very good about the pace and momentum.
The outlook, given the strength of the various pipelines, the strong booking momentum, the expectation, hope for renewal of the large government agency contract in the fourth quarter and our expectation of significant sales growth in the fourth quarter. Otherwise, it makes us confident that our fiscal fourth quarter will be our strongest ever, both the top line and bottom line that we're well positioned for continued and accelerated growth in fiscal 2015 and beyond.
To allow for some uncertainty related to the timing and award of the government contract and to provide additional conservatism, we're expecting or we've revised our annual guidance down 3% with the range to be between $34 million and $37 million.
So I'll just close and say we're pleased with our continued progress in each of the areas. We appreciate your support. I'd say we've never really felt more excited or confident about the business. When we had our kickoff meeting in the fall, after having made a lot of progress over the last years, we said we're here not to celebrate having reached the summit, but having reached base camp of a new whole mountain, which is the rapid expansion phase. We've spent all this money investing in infrastructure, doing all the things we've had to do to get to where we are, at the same time, thankfully growing revenue and profitability. But we really feel now that almost all our time now was spent on this question of hiring and ramping up 30 new Client Partners a year and making sure the flow-through is there.
So at this point, I'll turn the time over to Derek Hatch to just review some key metrics. I should note -- I think many of you know that Steve Young, a year -- a week ago was all of a sudden taken to the hospital for an emergency surgery that's not life threatening, but it's painful, and his recovery has been a little slower. But he's in good spirits and good health. We expect him to be back in the office next week, but he's not here to do that today. And so, Derek, we'll turn the time to you.